Chan Lynette Ws, Hebben-Wadey Alan, Kambakara Gedara Chandrika, McParland James
Salomons Institute for Applied Psychology, Canterbury Christ Church University, UK.
University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2025 Apr;30(2):212-228. doi: 10.1177/13591045241301644. Epub 2024 Dec 17.
BackgroundEthnic disparities in cancer prevalence and health outcomes have been widely documented in adults. However, less is known about the impact of ethnic differences in young cancer patients who present with complex needs along their developmental trajectories. The present review aimed to examine psychological outcomes amongst ethnically minoritised adolescents and young adults (AYAs) with cancer.MethodA systematic search was conducted on four databases using terms related to AYAs, cancer, ethnic minority and psychological outcomes. Quantitative studies of any design were included and screened against the eligibility criteria. Studies were rated for methodological quality and synthesised narratively.ResultsTwelve studies conducted in the United States were identified with mostly moderate to low quality and the evidence was mixed. Six studies found ethnic disparities in psychological outcomes: the majority demonstrated that ethnically minoritised AYAs experienced significantly more distress compared to White peers with cancer. Hispanic youths were highlighted as a vulnerable group that fared worse in their mental health compared to other minoritised youths. Longitudinal data showed that minoritised AYAs experienced more marked improvement in their psychological health over time compared to Caucasians.ConclusionThere is emerging evidence regarding inter-ethnic differences in psychological outcomes amongst AYAs with cancer. However, the findings are inconsistent, reflecting methodological weaknesses and the complexities of intersectionality impacting on mental health. Further cross-cultural research is necessary to substantiate these findings and elucidate mechanisms behind these inequalities to promote more equitable healthcare.
背景
癌症患病率和健康结果方面的种族差异在成年人中已有广泛记录。然而,对于在发育轨迹上有复杂需求的年轻癌症患者中种族差异的影响,我们了解得较少。本综述旨在研究少数族裔青少年和青年成人(AYAs)癌症患者的心理结果。
方法
使用与AYAs、癌症、少数族裔和心理结果相关的术语,对四个数据库进行了系统检索。纳入了任何设计的定量研究,并根据纳入标准进行筛选。对研究的方法学质量进行评分,并进行叙述性综合分析。
结果
共识别出12项在美国进行的研究,大多质量中等或较低,证据不一。6项研究发现心理结果存在种族差异:大多数研究表明,与患癌的白人同龄人相比,少数族裔AYAs经历的痛苦明显更多。西班牙裔青少年被视为弱势群体,其心理健康状况比其他少数族裔青少年更差。纵向数据显示,与白种人相比,少数族裔AYAs随着时间推移心理健康状况有更显著的改善。
结论
有新证据表明患癌AYAs的心理结果存在种族间差异。然而,研究结果并不一致,反映出方法学上的弱点以及交叉性对心理健康影响的复杂性。需要进一步的跨文化研究来证实这些发现,并阐明这些不平等背后的机制,以促进更公平的医疗保健。