McTavish Michael J, Jones Ian M, Smith Sandy M, Bourchier Robert S
Institute of Forestry and Conservation, John H. Daniels Faculty of Architecture, Landscape and Design, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada.
PLoS One. 2024 Dec 18;19(12):e0315071. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0315071. eCollection 2024.
Introduced Phragmites (Phragmites australis australis (Cav.) Trin. Ex Steud.) is one of the most invasive plants in North America. To supplement existing management tools, a classical biological control program began in Canada in 2019 using two host-specific stem-boring moths, Archanara neurica (Hübner) and Lenisa geminipuncta (Haworth) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). In this article, we summarize the first three years of monitoring data for L. geminipuncta and A. neurica as biological control agents for introduced Phragmites. First, we assess agent presence and activity in the initial years post-release based on feeding damage from long-term monitoring data across 30 release sites initiated between 2019 and 2023. Second, we investigate the within-site distribution of agent feeding damage to improve future monitoring and agent collection from nurse sites. Third, we report the results of an experiment to determine optimal release densities of A. neurica larvae. We found agent feeding damage at 92% of initial release sites in the first year and agent activity persisted at all of these sites into years two and three post-release. Patterns of agent feeding damage suggest that the agents disperse quickly through the patch following release, favouring the interior area over the edges of introduced Phragmites stands. Finally, releasing intermediate densities of 40 A. neurica larvae per release point was more efficient than releasing either units of 20 or 80 larvae. The results of the first three years of monitoring are highly encouraging for the introduced Phragmites biological control program. Insights from these early monitoring results will be used to refine optimal release strategies, improve our ability to locate egg-bearing stems at nurse sites to facilitate the collection and redistribution of agents to new release locations, and inform protocols for longer-term monitoring of impacts on the target weed once agents are established.
外来芦苇(Phragmites australis australis (Cav.) Trin. Ex Steud.)是北美最具入侵性的植物之一。为了补充现有的管理手段,2019年在加拿大启动了一项经典生物防治计划,使用两种寄主专一的蛀茎蛾,即Archanara neurica (Hübner) 和Lenisa geminipuncta (Haworth)(鳞翅目:夜蛾科)。在本文中,我们总结了将L. geminipuncta和A. neurica作为外来芦苇生物防治剂的前三年监测数据。首先,我们根据2019年至2023年期间启动的30个释放点的长期监测数据中的取食损伤情况,评估释放后最初几年中防治剂的存在和活动情况。其次,我们调查防治剂取食损伤在释放点内的分布情况,以改进未来的监测以及从保育地收集防治剂的工作。第三,我们报告一项实验的结果,以确定A. neurica幼虫的最佳释放密度。我们发现,第一年在92%的初始释放点有防治剂取食损伤,且在释放后的第二年和第三年,所有这些地点防治剂的活动仍持续存在。防治剂取食损伤的模式表明,防治剂在释放后会迅速在斑块中扩散,相较于外来芦苇群落边缘,更倾向于内部区域。最后,每个释放点释放40只A. neurica幼虫的中等密度比释放20只或80只幼虫更有效。前三年的监测结果对外来芦苇生物防治计划非常鼓舞人心。这些早期监测结果的见解将用于完善最佳释放策略,提高我们在保育地定位产卵茎的能力,以便于收集防治剂并将其重新分配到新的释放地点,还能为防治剂建立后对目标杂草影响的长期监测方案提供参考。