Methylation of cytosine in CpG dinucleotides is an epigenetic modification carried out by DNA-methyltransferases (DNMTs) that contributes to chromatin condensation and structure and, thus, to gene transcription regulation and chromosome stability. DNMT1 maintains the DNA methylation pattern of the genome at each cell cycle by copying it to the newly synthesized DNA strand during the S-phase. DNMT1 pharmacological inhibition as well as genetic knockout and knockdown, leads to passive DNA methylation loss. However, these strategies have been associated with different cell fates, even in the same cell background, suggesting that they can question the interpretation of the obtained results. Using a cell system in which endogenous DNMT1 is fused with an inducible degron and can be rapidly degraded, we found that in non-tumoral RPE-1 cells, DNMT1 loss progressively induced cell proliferation slowing-down and cell cycle arrest at the G1/S transition. The latter is due to p21 activation, which is partly mediated by p53 and leads to a global reduction in DNA methylation. DNMT1 restoration rescues cell proliferation, indicating that its deregulation is sensed as tunable cellular stress.