Alsem M W, Bakkum A, Ketelaar M, Willemen A M
Centre of Excellence for Rehabilitation Medicine, UMC Utrecht Brain Centre, University Medical Centre Utrecht and De Hoogstraat Rehabilitation Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Department of Rehabilitation, Physical Therapy Science & Sports, Wilhelmina Children's Hospital, University Medical Centre Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Eur J Pediatr. 2024 Dec 19;184(1):91. doi: 10.1007/s00431-024-05930-8.
There is a growing body of literature that recognizes the importance of shared decision-making (SDM) in the care for children with chronic conditions and/or disabilities. Although participation in SDM can be more or less active, the tuning between parents and professionals about the way they want to participate in SDM is often an implicit process, limiting parents' optimal involvement. Role definitions may support both partners in the process of SDM. We conducted a scoping review to investigate the available knowledge on the interpretation and variability of different roles of parents and professionals in SDM. In total, 43 articles were included and were subjected to data extraction and thematic coding. The findings show that roles are described in the literature by three themes: (1) active and passive involvement, (2) leadership in decision-making, and (3) six specific roles: informing, advocating, supporting, facilitating, coordinating, and interacting. Some, but not all, of these roles are described for parents as well as professionals.Conclusion: The literature provides a first definition of the various roles parents and professionals may take during SDM. However, the results do not inform how the described roles can be performed in clinical practice. Follow-up research is needed to develop and evaluate practical initiatives to achieve suitable roles for both parents and professionals. What is Known: • Parents often play a role in shared decision-making What is New: • Parents and professionals can play different and various roles in decision-making • Most described roles can be played by both parents and professionals.
越来越多的文献认识到共同决策(SDM)在慢性病和/或残疾儿童护理中的重要性。尽管参与共同决策的程度或多或少有所不同,但父母与专业人员之间就他们希望参与共同决策的方式进行协调往往是一个隐性过程,这限制了父母的最佳参与度。角色定义可能有助于双方在共同决策过程中发挥作用。我们进行了一项范围综述,以调查关于父母和专业人员在共同决策中不同角色的解释和变异性的现有知识。总共纳入了43篇文章,并对其进行了数据提取和主题编码。研究结果表明,文献中通过三个主题描述了角色:(1)积极和消极参与,(2)决策中的领导作用,以及(3)六个具体角色:提供信息、倡导、支持、促进、协调和互动。其中一些角色(但不是全部)同时针对父母和专业人员进行了描述。结论:文献首次对父母和专业人员在共同决策过程中可能扮演的各种角色进行了定义。然而,研究结果并未说明所描述的角色在临床实践中应如何履行。需要开展后续研究,以制定和评估切实可行的举措,使父母和专业人员都能发挥合适的角色。已知信息:• 父母通常在共同决策中发挥作用 新发现:• 父母和专业人员在决策中可以扮演不同且多样的角色 • 大多数所描述的角色父母和专业人员都可以扮演。