Nadel Peter, Smith Kevin M
Tufts University, 169 Holland Street Somerville, Medford, MA, 02144, USA.
J Public Health Policy. 2025 Mar;46(1):149-157. doi: 10.1057/s41271-024-00540-y. Epub 2024 Dec 18.
Public health policies can dramatically shape government responses to emerging public health crises. In cases where a response is inadequate, it's natural to seek improvements to these policies to achieve better results in future crises. However, while policies and outcomes are usually visible, the complex dynamics that link them are seldom obvious. Obscure social network structures, power and information asymmetries, and political agendas all influence the translation of policy to action or inaction. Intergovernmental communications are often the only primary sources for researchers investigating these hidden but crucial factors. Public records laws in many countries make such documents available upon request, but their structure, format, and scale are rarely accessible in practice. Fortunately, recent advances in free and open-source data science tools are making this problem tractable. In this visual brief, we demonstrate using such tools to mine a large image dataset and reconstruct decision-making during the Flint Water Crisis in Michigan, USA.
公共卫生政策能够极大地塑造政府对新出现的公共卫生危机的应对方式。在应对措施不足的情况下,寻求改进这些政策以在未来危机中取得更好的结果是很自然的。然而,虽然政策和结果通常是可见的,但将它们联系起来的复杂动态却很少明显。模糊的社会网络结构、权力和信息不对称以及政治议程都会影响政策转化为行动或不行动。政府间通信往往是研究这些隐藏但关键因素的研究人员的唯一主要来源。许多国家的公共记录法规定,应要求提供此类文件,但实际上它们的结构、格式和规模很少能够获取。幸运的是,免费和开源数据科学工具的最新进展正在使这个问题变得易于处理。在本可视化简报中,我们展示了使用此类工具挖掘一个大型图像数据集并重建美国密歇根州弗林特水危机期间的决策过程。