Du Mont Janice, Cheung Rachel, Burley Joseph Friedman, Kosa Sarah Daisy, Kelly C Emma, Jakubiec Brittany A E, Brouillard-Coyle Sydney, Macdonald Sheila
Women's College Research Institute, Women's College Hospital, 76 Grenville St, Toronto, ON, M5S 1B2, Canada.
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, 155 College St, Toronto, ON, M5T 3M7, Canada.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2024 Dec 18;22(1):163. doi: 10.1186/s12961-024-01245-0.
Transgender (trans) people experience high rates of sexual assault (SA) and intimate partner violence (IPV) and seldom receive the care and supports they need post-victimization. However, there is little to no research that aids in the development or improvement of related interventions. We undertook a study to build a novel Canadian research agenda on SA/IPV against trans people to guide future work and address these profound gaps in knowledge.
Guided by the Child Health and Nutrition Research Initiative (CHNRI) method for research priority-setting, we developed and circulated two consecutive surveys to a multi-stakeholder group of government decision makers; mental health, health and social service providers, researchers and trans communities, among others, who proposed research questions related to preventing and addressing SA/IPV against trans persons. The initial survey launched March 2021 garnered responses from 213 stakeholders. These items were cleaned and collated into 20 final questions that fell within seven thematic areas. The refined research questions were evaluated in August 2021 on predefined criteria for answerability, feasibility, impact and equity by 79 of 95 survey 1 respondents who agreed to participate in the second survey (response rate = 83.2%). The questions were ranked using a research priority score calculated by dividing the sum of all the answers for each question across the four criteria by the number of answers received.
All questions were highly rated on each individual criterion and each had an overall research priority score of above 80%, with the most highly ranked question falling within the theme, "improving quality and implementation of education and training: How can training (e.g., for university/college students, educators, nurses, physicians, social workers, police, lawyers, security guards) be improved to better support trans survivors of sexual assault and intimate partner violence?".
These questions form Canada's first research agenda on SA/IPV against trans people. Together, they reflect the insights of stakeholder groups who have been historically excluded from research priority-setting processes and will guide future and much-needed work on the topic. Actionable information on preventing and addressing SA/IPV against trans persons will help reduce negative outcomes associated with being victimized.
跨性别者遭受性侵犯(SA)和亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)的比例很高,在受害后很少得到他们所需的护理和支持。然而,几乎没有研究有助于相关干预措施的开发或改进。我们开展了一项研究,以建立一个关于针对跨性别者的性侵犯/亲密伴侣暴力的加拿大新研究议程,以指导未来的工作并填补这些知识上的巨大空白。
在儿童健康与营养研究倡议(CHNRI)确定研究优先级的方法指导下,我们连续向一个由政府决策者、心理健康、健康和社会服务提供者、研究人员以及跨性别群体等多方利益相关者组成的群体发放了两份调查问卷,他们提出了与预防和应对针对跨性别者的性侵犯/亲密伴侣暴力相关的研究问题。2021年3月发起的初始调查收到了213名利益相关者的回复。这些问题经过清理和整理,形成了20个最终问题,这些问题属于七个主题领域。2021年8月,95名参与第一次调查的受访者中有79人(回复率=83.2%)根据预先确定的可回答性、可行性、影响和公平性标准,对细化后的研究问题进行了评估。通过将每个问题在四个标准上的所有答案总和除以收到的答案数量来计算研究优先级分数,从而对问题进行排名。
所有问题在每个单独标准上的评分都很高,每个问题的总体研究优先级分数都超过80%,排名最高的问题属于“提高教育和培训的质量与实施:如何改进培训(例如针对大学生、教育工作者、护士、医生、社会工作者、警察、律师、保安),以更好地支持性侵犯和亲密伴侣暴力的跨性别幸存者?”这一主题。
这些问题构成了加拿大首个关于针对跨性别者的性侵犯/亲密伴侣暴力的研究议程。它们共同反映了历史上被排除在研究优先级设定过程之外的利益相关者群体的见解,并将指导未来关于该主题的急需的工作。关于预防和应对针对跨性别者的性侵犯/亲密伴侣暴力的可操作信息将有助于减少与受害相关的负面结果。