Ogunwale Akintayo, Ajayi IkeOluwapo, Bamgboye Eniola, Adamu Al-Mukhtar, Bello Musa, Olawuwo Morenikeji, Fagbamigbe Adeniyi, Akinyemi Joshua, Ozodiegwu Ifeoma
Department of Public Health, College of Health Sciences, Bowen University, Iwo, Osun, Nigeria.
Epidemiology and Biostatistics Research Unit, Institute for Advanced Medical Research and Training (IAMRAT), College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Oyo, Nigeria.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Dec 18;24(1):1572. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-12013-9.
Unplanned and rapid urbanization within Nigerian cities with the attendant environmental consequences may hinder achieving malaria elimination goal. Presently, there are limited qualitative studies on malaria case management and care-seeking patterns by settlement type in urban areas in Nigeria. This study, investigated malaria-related health seeking behaviours among different settlement types in Ibadan and Kano metropolises, Nigeria.
This qualitative study involved conduct of nine Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) sessions among community members and 20 Key Informant interviews (KIIs) with healthcare providers and community stakeholders in each metropolis. Participants were purposively drawn from three settlement types - formal, informal and urban slum. Pretested FGD and KII guides were used to collect data. Data were subjected to thematic content analysis.
Government-owned health facilities especially Primary Health Care (PHC) facilities was a major place identified as where many community members prefer to seek care for suspected malaria infection. Reasons adduced included proximity of facilities and services affordability. A common viewpoint was that most community members in informal and slum communities in both metropolises often patronize Proprietary Patent Medicine Vendors (PPMVs) or drug sellers as the first point for treatment of suspected malaria infection. Adduced reasons included poverty and non-availability of 24 h services in PHC facilities. High cost of treatment, poor attitude of health workers, long waiting time and cultural beliefs were identified as key factors influencing community members' decision not to seek care in health facilities. It was noted that the rich prefer to seek treatment in private hospitals, while the poor usually visit PHCs or resort to other options like buying drugs from PPMVs or use herbal drugs.
The standard practice of seeking care in health facilities was influenced by diverse factors including treatment cost, health workers' attitude and waiting time in health facilities. A commoner practice of seeking care from patent medicine vendors and herbal drug sellers among informal settlements and slums dwellers calls for public health interventions. Specifically, the provision of free or affordable malaria care in health facilities and patient-friendly environments; and training of non-formal care providers on appropriate malaria care and referral to health facilities are recommended.
尼日利亚城市中无规划且快速的城市化及其带来的环境后果可能会阻碍实现疟疾消除目标。目前,关于尼日利亚城市地区按居住类型划分的疟疾病例管理和就医模式的定性研究有限。本研究调查了尼日利亚伊巴丹和卡诺大都市不同居住类型中与疟疾相关的就医行为。
这项定性研究包括在社区成员中开展9次焦点小组讨论(FGD),并对每个大都市的医疗服务提供者和社区利益相关者进行20次关键 informant 访谈(KII)。参与者是从三种居住类型——正规、非正规和城市贫民窟中有目的地抽取的。使用经过预测试的FGD和KII指南收集数据。对数据进行主题内容分析。
政府所有的卫生设施,特别是初级卫生保健(PHC)设施,是许多社区成员首选的寻求疑似疟疾感染治疗的主要场所。提出的理由包括设施距离近和服务价格可承受。一个共同的观点是,两个大都市中非正规和贫民窟社区的大多数社区成员通常会首先光顾专利药品销售商(PPMV)或药品销售商来治疗疑似疟疾感染。提出的理由包括贫困以及初级卫生保健设施中没有24小时服务。治疗费用高、卫生工作者态度差、等待时间长和文化信仰被确定为影响社区成员不在卫生设施就医的关键因素。值得注意的是,富人更喜欢在私立医院寻求治疗,而穷人通常去初级卫生保健中心或 resort 于其他选择,如从专利药品销售商那里购买药品或使用草药。
在卫生设施寻求治疗的标准做法受到多种因素的影响,包括治疗费用、卫生工作者的态度以及在卫生设施中的等待时间。非正规住区和贫民窟居民中常见的从专利药品销售商和草药销售商那里寻求治疗的做法需要公共卫生干预。具体而言,建议在卫生设施中提供免费或负担得起的疟疾护理以及对患者友好的环境;并对非正规护理提供者进行适当的疟疾护理培训以及转诊到卫生设施的培训。