Tsui Joseph L-H, Zhang Mengyan, Sambaturu Prathyush, Busch-Moreno Simon, Suchard Marc A, Pybus Oliver G, Flaxman Seth, Semenova Elizaveta, Kraemer Moritz U G
Department of Biology, University of Oxford, Oxford OX1 3SZ, United Kingdom.
Pandemic Sciences Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford OX3 7DQ, United Kingdom.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 Dec 24;121(52):e2412424121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2412424121. Epub 2024 Dec 19.
Tracking the spread of emerging pathogens is critical to the design of timely and effective public health responses. Policymakers face the challenge of allocating finite resources for testing and surveillance across locations, with the goal of maximizing the information obtained about the underlying trends in prevalence and incidence. We model this decision-making process as an iterative node classification problem on an undirected and unweighted graph, in which nodes represent locations and edges represent movement of infectious agents among them. To begin, a single node is randomly selected for testing and determined to be either infected or uninfected. Test feedback is then used to update estimates of the probability of unobserved nodes being infected and to inform the selection of nodes for testing at the next iterations, until certain test budget is exhausted. Using this framework, we evaluate and compare the performance of previously developed active learning policies for node selection, including Node Entropy and Bayesian Active Learning by Disagreement. We explore the performance of these policies under different outbreak scenarios using simulated outbreaks on both synthetic and empirical networks. Further, we propose a policy that considers the distance-weighted average entropy of infection predictions among neighbors of each candidate node. Our proposed policy outperforms existing ones in most outbreak scenarios given small test budgets, highlighting the need to consider an exploration-exploitation trade-off in policy design. Our findings could inform the design of cost-effective surveillance strategies for emerging and endemic pathogens and reduce uncertainties associated with early risk assessments in resource-constrained situations.
追踪新兴病原体的传播对于及时设计有效的公共卫生应对措施至关重要。政策制定者面临着在不同地点分配有限资源用于检测和监测的挑战,目标是最大限度地获取有关患病率和发病率潜在趋势的信息。我们将这一决策过程建模为一个无向无加权图上的迭代节点分类问题,其中节点代表地点,边代表传染病原体在这些地点之间的传播。首先,随机选择一个节点进行检测,并确定其是否感染。然后利用检测反馈来更新未观察节点感染概率的估计值,并为下一次迭代的检测节点选择提供信息,直到用尽特定的检测预算。使用这个框架,我们评估并比较了先前开发的用于节点选择的主动学习策略的性能,包括节点熵和分歧贝叶斯主动学习。我们通过在合成网络和实证网络上模拟疫情,探索这些策略在不同疫情场景下的性能。此外,我们提出了一种考虑每个候选节点邻居感染预测的距离加权平均熵的策略。在检测预算较小的大多数疫情场景中,我们提出的策略优于现有策略,突出了在政策设计中考虑探索与利用权衡的必要性。我们的研究结果可为新兴和地方性病原体的经济高效监测策略设计提供参考,并减少资源受限情况下早期风险评估的不确定性。