Masroor Taleaa, Martins Russell S, Arif Aiman, Chughtai Talaiha, Madhani Falak, Zahid Nida, Zeeshan Sana, Vohra Lubna, Khan Salima, Hidayat Mishal, Amir Hamna, Soofi Sajid Bashir, Sattar Abida K
Department of Surgery, John Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Division of Thoracic Surgery, Department of Surgery, Hackensack Meridian School of Medicine, Hackensack Meridian Health Network, Edison, New Jersey, USA.
J Glob Health. 2024 Dec 20;14:04255. doi: 10.7189/jogh.14.04255.
Clinical breast exam (CBE) by outreach healthcare workers (HCW) may help downstage breast cancer in resource-limited areas where mammography may not be feasible. We evaluated the effectiveness of a pilot cascade-model training programme for HCWs in remote areas of Pakistan.
The training programme comprised three phases. In phase one, fellowship-trained breast surgeons at a metropolitan academic centre trained six HCWs to perform CBEs. In phase two, these six HCWs (master trainers) trained 15 additional HCWs, implementing cascade training. In phase three, the consultant breast surgeon conducted a re-evaluation and refresher course for all 21 HCWs at least one year after the original training session. We assessed CBE ability and skills through pre- and post-changes through self-reported confidence and direct observation of procedural skills.
Significant improvements in learners' self-reported confidence and CBE skills were observed in both phases one and two. The median scores in the learners' post-training self-reported confidence and CBE skills (inspection, palpation, and lymph node examination) improved by 20% and 46.2%, respectively, indicating excellent learning outcomes of the cascade training sessions. Phase three showed sustained high scores in self-reported confidence and CBE skills more than one year later.
Mass training of outreach HCWs in remote regions in performing CBE may be possible with a structured multiphase cascade-training model and may be an important step in downstaging symptomatic breast cancer in low-resource settings.
在乳腺钼靶检查不可行的资源有限地区,外展医护人员进行的临床乳腺检查(CBE)可能有助于降低乳腺癌分期。我们评估了巴基斯坦偏远地区针对医护人员的试点级联模型培训计划的有效性。
培训计划包括三个阶段。在第一阶段,一所大城市学术中心接受过专科培训的乳腺外科医生培训了6名医护人员进行CBE。在第二阶段,这6名医护人员(主培训师)又培训了15名医护人员,实施级联培训。在第三阶段,乳腺外科顾问医生在原培训课程至少一年后为所有21名医护人员进行了重新评估和进修课程。我们通过自我报告的信心和对操作技能的直接观察,评估培训前后CBE能力和技能的变化。
在第一阶段和第二阶段,学习者自我报告的信心和CBE技能均有显著提高。学习者培训后自我报告的信心和CBE技能(检查、触诊和淋巴结检查)的中位数得分分别提高了20%和46.2%,表明级联培训课程取得了优异的学习成果。第三阶段显示,一年多后自我报告的信心和CBE技能得分持续较高。
采用结构化的多阶段级联培训模式,对偏远地区的外展医护人员进行大规模CBE培训是可行的,这可能是在资源匮乏地区降低有症状乳腺癌分期的重要一步。