Dobbie Laurence J, Birney Susie, Breen Cathy, Bryant Sheree, Clare Ken, Ciudin Andreea, Felsenreich Daniel M, Halford Jason C G, Heneghan Helen, Lorenzo Nicola Di, Mooney Vicki, Parmar Chetan, O'Connell Jean, O'Malley Grace, Woodward Euan, Yumuk Volkan D, Peterli Ralph, McGowan Barbara
School of Life Course & Population Sciences, Kings College London, UK.
Irish Coalition for People Living with Obesity (ICPO), Dublin, Ireland.
Int J Surg. 2025 Feb 1;111(2):1711-1723. doi: 10.1097/JS9.0000000000002171.
Bariatric and metabolic surgery tourism (BMT) is becoming an increasingly popular route to treatment for patients living with obesity. Recent reports have highlighted that some patients travelling abroad for bariatric surgery have received inadequate care, fraudulent care, and, tragically, some cases have resulted in death. This study aimed to define consensus in Europe regarding safe practices concerning BMT.
IFSO-EC, EASO and ECPO initiated a task force to delineate safe practices in BMT. Two expert European panels were convened, one comprised of healthcare professionals (identified from EASO and IFSO-EC) and the other of patient representatives (identified from ECPO). The study utilized a modified Delphi consensus methodology, and 135 questions were administered. Surveys were conducted anonymously online, and consensus was defined as 70% agreement. Themes analyzed regarding BMT included regulation, pre-operative evaluation, operative care, post-operative care, advertising and online information.
One hundred and nineteen healthcare professionals and 88 patient representatives participated from 26 countries. The healthcare professional panel included 66 bariatric surgeons, 28 endocrinologists, 18 dietitians, three nurses, two psychologists, one general practitioner and one gastroenterologist. Three questionnaire rounds were conducted for the healthcare professional panel, and two were performed for the patient representative panel. Consensus recommendations were given across all themes relevant to BMT. These included evaluating and managing psychological health, sleep apnea, cardiovascular disease, liver health and dietetic assessment. The recommendations covered the requirements for regulatory standards, including surgeon accreditation and procedural volume. They also included recommendations regarding patient education, standardized operative care, online information provision, and follow-up.
Through collaboration with healthcare professionals and patients living with obesity, we provide European recommendations regarding safe practices concerning BMT. Further evaluation is required regarding outcomes following BMT. These data, alongside the Delphi consensus recommendations, will inform BMT clinical guideline development.
减肥与代谢手术旅游(BMT)正日益成为肥胖患者寻求治疗的热门途径。最近的报告强调,一些出国接受减肥手术的患者得到的护理不足、护理存在欺诈行为,而且悲剧的是,一些案例导致了死亡。本研究旨在确定欧洲在BMT安全实践方面的共识。
国际肥胖与代谢病外科联盟欧洲分会(IFSO-EC)、欧洲肥胖症研究学会(EASO)和欧洲肥胖症患者组织(ECPO)发起了一个特别工作组来界定BMT的安全实践。召集了两个欧洲专家小组,一个由医疗保健专业人员组成(从EASO和IFSO-EC中确定),另一个由患者代表组成(从ECPO中确定)。该研究采用了改良的德尔菲共识方法,并提出了135个问题。调查通过在线匿名进行,共识定义为70%的同意率。分析的关于BMT的主题包括监管、术前评估、手术护理、术后护理、广告和在线信息。
来自26个国家的119名医疗保健专业人员和88名患者代表参与了研究。医疗保健专业人员小组包括66名减肥外科医生、28名内分泌学家、18名营养师、3名护士、2名心理学家、1名全科医生和1名胃肠病学家。对医疗保健专业人员小组进行了三轮问卷调查,对患者代表小组进行了两轮问卷调查。针对与BMT相关的所有主题给出了共识建议。这些建议包括评估和管理心理健康、睡眠呼吸暂停、心血管疾病、肝脏健康和饮食评估。这些建议涵盖了监管标准的要求,包括外科医生认证和手术量。它们还包括关于患者教育、标准化手术护理、在线信息提供和随访的建议。
通过与医疗保健专业人员和肥胖患者合作,我们提供了关于BMT安全实践的欧洲建议。需要对BMT后的结果进行进一步评估。这些数据以及德尔菲共识建议将为BMT临床指南的制定提供参考。