Glebko Nadezhda, Kharitonova Alyona, Kosova Ekaterina, Gorbunova Elena
Department of Psychology, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia.
Cogn Process. 2025 May;26(2):457-470. doi: 10.1007/s10339-024-01253-6. Epub 2024 Dec 23.
As technological interfaces are relatively new cultural tools, regular interaction can lead to new psychological phenomena, like the baby duck syndrome, where users favor old interfaces over updates. This syndrome is seen as a cognitive bias in human-computer interaction. Two studies were conducted: Study 1 on an Airbnb app (old vs. new versions), and Study 2 on a self-developed website (blue vs. purple design). Subjects completed sequential five usability tasks in two blocks with the resting between. Experimental groups engaged with different interface versions, while control groups used the same one. After completing tasks, subjects filled questionnaires about interface interaction. Study 1 showed significantly higher preference for the old Airbnb version, though scores varied by group. Study 2 revealed a trend of reduced scores in experimental groups on second assessment, not seen in controls. Version-based rating differences were insignificant. Overall, Studies 1 and 2 indicated baby duck syndrome is challenging to study in labs, suggesting it emerges when users are genuinely engaged with the interface. This article has both theoretical and experimental significance for studying the emergence of psychological phenomena in human-digital interaction. As a practical application, the obtained results can be useful for correct development updates for interfaces.
由于技术界面是相对较新的文化工具,频繁互动可能会导致新的心理现象,比如“幼鸭综合征”,即用户更喜欢旧界面而非更新后的界面。这种综合征在人机交互中被视为一种认知偏差。研究人员开展了两项研究:研究1针对爱彼迎应用程序(旧版本与新版本),研究2针对一个自行开发的网站(蓝色设计与紫色设计)。受试者分两个阶段依次完成五项可用性任务,中间有休息时间。实验组使用不同的界面版本,而对照组使用相同的版本。完成任务后,受试者填写有关界面交互的问卷。研究1显示,受试者对爱彼迎旧版本的偏好明显更高,不过得分因组别而异。研究2显示,实验组在第二次评估时得分有下降趋势,而对照组则没有。基于版本的评分差异不显著。总体而言,研究1和研究2表明,“幼鸭综合征”在实验室环境中很难进行研究,这表明该现象是在用户真正与界面互动时出现的。本文对于研究人类与数字交互中心理现象的出现具有理论和实验意义。作为一项实际应用,所得结果对于界面的正确开发更新可能会有所帮助。