Foglabenchi Lily Haritu, Stöckl Heidi, Marchant Tanya
Department of Disease Control, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel St, London, WC1E 7HT, UK.
Maternal and Child Health Unit, Cameroon Baptist Convention Health Services, Finance Junction, P.O Box 1, Bamenda, North West Region, Cameroon.
Reprod Health. 2024 Dec 23;21(1):195. doi: 10.1186/s12978-024-01928-5.
The reduction of maternal mortality has stagnated globally. Estimates project a rise to 140.9 deaths per 100,000 live births by 2030, which is double the Sustainable Development Goal target. Male involvement in pregnancy care has been proposed as an intervention to improve maternal and child health outcomes. However, there is limited understanding of how communities view the role of men beyond the instrumentalist approach that only targets men as accompanying partners without altering the underlying gender and socio-cultural determinants that shape their involvement in pregnancy care. This study broadens existing research by exploring and and contextualising the role of male partners during pregnancy in Bamenda, Cameroon.
This study employed a qualitative design underpinned by symbolic interactionism. We conducted 68 semi-structured interviews (SSIs) and three focus group discussions (FGDs) with purposively selected pregnant women (n = 38 SSIs; n = 2, FGD) and male partners (n = 30 SSIs; n = 1, FGD) in an urban hospital in the North West Regional capital-Bamenda. Nvivo was used for data management and subsequently, we performed thematic analysis using a critical discourse lens to generate manifest and latent interpretations of study findings.
The role of male partners reflected hegemonic masculinity and was broadly conceptualised in three categories: breadwinner, protector/comforter, and 'sender' for antenatal care. Perceptions of men's role differed between male and female participants. While women sought male involvement for pragmatic reasons like joint attendance of antenatal care, psychosocial support (affirmation) and assistance with domestic chores, men limited their involvement to roles that matched gendered preconceptions of masculinity like financial support for antenatal fees, maternal nutrition and birth supplies. Nonetheless, the perceived benefits for antenatal attendance was expressed by some men in terms of the direct access it gives them to pregnancy-related education from experts, paternal bonding and the appeal of fast-track services for couples.
Male involvement in maternal and child health in Bamenda Health District is an extension and reflection of how patriarchal norms on masculinity are constructed and adapted in this setting. To address gaps in male involvement, intervention designers and implementers will need to take into account prevailing culture-specific norms while deconstructing and leveraging masculine ideals to situate male involvement in the prenatal context.
全球孕产妇死亡率的下降已陷入停滞。据估计,到2030年,每10万例活产的孕产妇死亡人数将升至140.9人,这是可持续发展目标所设定目标的两倍。男性参与孕期保健已被提议作为改善母婴健康结局的一项干预措施。然而,对于社区如何看待男性的角色,人们的了解有限,目前的认识仅停留在工具主义方法上,即只把男性视为陪伴伴侣的人,而没有改变影响其参与孕期保健的潜在性别和社会文化决定因素。本研究通过探索和阐述喀麦隆巴门达地区男性伴侣在孕期的角色,拓展了现有研究。
本研究采用以符号互动主义为基础的定性设计。我们在西北地区首府巴门达的一家城市医院,对有目的地挑选出的孕妇(38次半结构式访谈;2次焦点小组讨论)和男性伴侣(30次半结构式访谈;1次焦点小组讨论)进行了68次半结构式访谈和3次焦点小组讨论。使用NVivo进行数据管理,随后,我们运用批判性话语视角进行主题分析,以对研究结果产生显性和隐性的解读。
男性伴侣的角色反映了霸权男性气质,大致可归纳为三类:养家糊口者、保护者/安慰者以及产前保健的“送行者”。男性和女性参与者对男性角色的看法存在差异。女性寻求男性参与是出于务实的原因,比如共同参加产前保健、获得心理社会支持(肯定)以及家务协助,而男性则将其参与局限于符合男性气质性别成见的角色,比如支付产前费用、为孕妇提供营养和分娩用品的经济支持。尽管如此,一些男性表示,产前检查的好处在于能让他们直接从专家那里获得与怀孕相关的教育、建立父子关系以及享受夫妻快速通道服务。
巴门达健康区男性参与母婴健康是父权制男性气质规范在该环境中如何构建和调适情况的一种延伸和反映。为弥补男性参与方面的差距,干预措施的设计者和实施者需要在解构和利用男性理想观念以将男性参与置于产前背景的同时,考虑到当地特定的主流文化规范。