Caldas Afonso Sara, Caria Ramalhao Nuno, Cavalheiro Ana, Trepa Ana
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Centro Hospitalar Universitário de Santo António, Porto, PRT.
Cureus. 2024 Nov 23;16(11):e74295. doi: 10.7759/cureus.74295. eCollection 2024 Nov.
This literature review explores the role of biofeedback therapy (BFT) in managing functional fecal incontinence (FFI) in children - a common condition with a substantial impact on the quality of life. FFI diagnosis relies primarily on medical history and thorough physical examination and is categorized by the Rome IV criteria into functional constipation (FC) and functional nonretentive fecal incontinence (FNRFI). Treatment options for FFI remain limited, particularly for FNRFI. BFT employs electronic or mechanical devices, such as rectal probes or surface electrodes, to provide real-time feedback on muscle activity and rectal pressure. This feedback allows patients to better understand and control their pelvic floor muscles, improving coordination between contraction during stool retention and relaxation during defecation. It also plays a role in rectal sensory awareness, enabling patients to respond appropriately to the urge to defecate. BFT has been considered an option in refractory cases, although evidence supporting its routine use is still emerging. We conducted a comprehensive literature search focusing on studies from the past 24 years that evaluated BFT for pediatric FFI. Five relevant studies were identified and analyzed, each utilizing BFT in combination with various treatment modalities. Two studies, both randomized controlled trials (RCT) and with the largest sample, focused on the treatment of FNRFI, both concluding that BFT should be used in FNRFI refractory to conventional treatment. Another two studies, one RCT and a retrospective study, focused on patients with FC. The first did not show any additional value in the use of BFT, while the second showed positive results. Comparing both studies, they had very different methodologies and treatment plans, but besides these results, in both studies, they concluded that when selecting a treatment plan for a child with FFI, an alternative or additional treatment with BFT should be considered. Finally, the last study, a quasi-experimental study, did not differentiate between FC or FNRFI and compared the use of BFT to percutaneous tibial nerve stimulation (PTNS). Although they showed that there were slightly better results when using PTNS, they concluded that both PTNS and BFT are effective modalities in treating children with FFI in addition to conventional treatment. Overall, BFT showed positive outcomes, with no safety issues reported. BFT appears to be a useful, non-invasive option for pediatric FFI, both FC and FNRFI, especially in cases unresponsive to conventional therapies. When used in a tailored, multimodal approach, BFT holds the potential to improve continence and quality of life in children with this challenging condition, and given that 15% of children with FFI, specifically FNRFI, continue to experience symptoms into adulthood, it is crucial to consider these treatment options early to potentially reduce this rate. Besides this, more research is needed to conclude the long-term effects and to establish standardized pediatric rehabilitation protocols.
本综述探讨了生物反馈疗法(BFT)在治疗儿童功能性大便失禁(FFI)中的作用——这是一种对生活质量有重大影响的常见病症。FFI的诊断主要依赖病史和全面的体格检查,并根据罗马IV标准分为功能性便秘(FC)和功能性无潴留性大便失禁(FNRFI)。FFI的治疗选择仍然有限,尤其是FNRFI。BFT使用电子或机械设备,如直肠探头或表面电极,来提供肌肉活动和直肠压力的实时反馈。这种反馈使患者能够更好地理解和控制盆底肌肉,改善排便时的保留收缩和排便时的放松之间的协调性。它在直肠感觉意识方面也发挥作用,使患者能够对排便冲动做出适当反应。BFT一直被视为难治性病例的一种选择,尽管支持其常规使用的证据仍在不断涌现。我们进行了一项全面的文献检索,重点关注过去24年中评估BFT治疗儿童FFI的研究。共识别并分析了五项相关研究,每项研究都将BFT与各种治疗方式联合使用。两项研究,均为随机对照试验(RCT)且样本量最大,聚焦于FNRFI的治疗,两者均得出结论,即BFT应用于对传统治疗无效的FNRFI。另外两项研究,一项RCT和一项回顾性研究,聚焦于FC患者。第一项研究未显示BFT使用有任何额外价值,而第二项研究显示出积极结果。比较这两项研究,它们的方法和治疗方案差异很大,但除此之外,在两项研究中,他们都得出结论,在为FFI儿童选择治疗方案时,应考虑将BFT作为一种替代或附加治疗。最后,最后一项研究,一项准实验研究,未区分FC或FNRFI,并将BFT的使用与经皮胫神经刺激(PTNS)进行了比较。尽管他们表明使用PTNS时结果略好,但他们得出结论,除传统治疗外,PTNS和BFT都是治疗儿童FFI的有效方式。总体而言,BFT显示出积极结果,未报告安全问题。BFT似乎是治疗FC和FNRFI儿童FFI的一种有用的、非侵入性的选择,尤其是在对传统疗法无反应的病例中。当以量身定制的多模式方法使用时,BFT有潜力改善患有这种具有挑战性病症的儿童的控便能力和生活质量,鉴于15%的FFI儿童,特别是FNRFI儿童,成年后仍有症状,尽早考虑这些治疗选择以潜在降低这一比例至关重要。除此之外,还需要更多研究来确定长期影响并建立标准化的儿科康复方案。