Poland-McClain Willa, Rai Abha, Archdeacon Natalie, Shallal Grace, Mulanovich Gabriela Salmon, Tallman Paula
Loyola University Chicago, IL, USA.
Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, Lima, Peru.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2024 Dec 24:15248380241306016. doi: 10.1177/15248380241306016.
In this article, we review existing interventions to prevent gender-based violence (GBV) in Latin American contexts to evaluate the extent to which this work incorporates cultural responsivity-meaning whether the interventions consider the unique norms, identities, and attributes of specific cultures. We follow Arksey and O'Malley's steps for conducting systematic scoping reviews. We reviewed articles from 2003 to 2023 across 12 databases. Fifteen peer-reviewed articles met the criteria for inclusion, which included being published in English or Spanish, focused on proposed or implemented interventions to prevent GBV based in Latin America, and published in the last 20 years. The selected studies contained information about separate GBV interventions (proposed or implemented) in 10 different countries in Latin America, in both rural and urban contexts. We categorized five interventions as most culturally responsive, six studies as moderately culturally responsive, and four studies as showing minimal attention to cultural responsivity. We found that culturally responsive interventions tended to involve working closely with men and women in local communities as "peer facilitators" or "community-based researchers." These interventions challenged socio-cultural norms related to gender, family, and parenting, including attention to machismo and other forms of hegemonic masculinity. The present study is the first one to examine cultural responsiveness within GBV interventions in Latin America, and it is relevant for researchers, service providers, and communities in Latin America who are concerned with preventing GBV.
在本文中,我们回顾了拉丁美洲背景下预防性别暴力(GBV)的现有干预措施,以评估这项工作在多大程度上纳入了文化适应性,即干预措施是否考虑了特定文化的独特规范、身份和特征。我们遵循阿克西和奥马利进行系统综述的步骤。我们检索了2003年至2023年期间12个数据库中的文章。15篇经过同行评审的文章符合纳入标准,包括以英文或西班牙文发表,聚焦于拉丁美洲预防性别暴力的拟议或实施的干预措施,且发表于过去20年。所选研究包含了拉丁美洲10个不同国家在农村和城市背景下单独的性别暴力干预措施(拟议或实施)的信息。我们将五项干预措施归类为最具文化适应性,六项研究归类为具有中等文化适应性,四项研究归类为对文化适应性关注最少。我们发现,具有文化适应性的干预措施往往倾向于与当地社区的男性和女性密切合作,将他们作为“同伴促进者”或“社区研究人员”。这些干预措施挑战了与性别、家庭和育儿相关的社会文化规范,包括对大男子主义和其他形式的霸权男性气质的关注。本研究是第一项考察拉丁美洲性别暴力干预措施中文化适应性的研究,对关注预防性别暴力的拉丁美洲研究人员、服务提供者和社区具有参考价值。