Egelko Aron, Florescu Natalie, Siegel Jacob, Tomkins Anastasiia, Erkmen Cherie
Department of General Surgery, Temple University Hospital, Philadelphia, PA.
Lewis Katz School of Medicine, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA.
J Surg Educ. 2025 Feb;82(2):103372. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2024.103372. Epub 2024 Dec 24.
LGBTQ medical students and surgery residents face myriad structural barriers. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) reports 492 pieces of state-level legislation targeting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) people in the past year. These bills including bans on medical care, "don't say gay" bills, exclusion from anti-discrimination protections, and more. These bills may limit where medical students pursue surgical training STUDY DESIGN: The Movement Advancement Project and the ACLU legislative databases were consulted to determine whether states (plus Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia) currently had or were actively considering anti-LGBTQ legislation. This information was then mapped against data from the 2023 National Residency Match Program. US News rankings of top surgical training programs were utilized as well.
There were 2803 general surgical training spots, of which 1597 (57%) were located in states which currently have anti-LGBTQ legislation in place. 245 (9%) of training spots are in states which do not have such legislation but are currently considering anti-LGBTQ legislation. Of the top 20 residency programs, 11 (55%) were in states with anti-LGBTQ legislation. In affiliated specialties, 50 (54%), 118 (57%), and 24 (49%) surgical training positions for integrated vascular, plastic, and thoracic surgery, respectively, are in states that currently have anti-LGBTQ legislation in place. In total, 63% of fellowship opportunities were in states with Anti-LGBTQ legislation in place CONCLUSION: A majority of graduate surgical education occurs in states with anti-LGBTQ legislation, potentially limiting residency options for people who value protection of LGBTQ rights.
LGBTQ医学生和外科住院医师面临着众多结构性障碍。美国公民自由联盟(ACLU)报告称,在过去一年里,有492项州级立法针对女同性恋、男同性恋、双性恋、跨性别者和酷儿(LGBTQ)群体。这些法案包括医疗护理禁令、“不要说同性恋”法案、被排除在反歧视保护之外等等。这些法案可能会限制医学生进行外科培训的地点。
查阅了运动促进项目和ACLU的立法数据库,以确定各州(以及波多黎各和哥伦比亚特区)目前是否有或正在积极考虑反LGBTQ立法。然后将这些信息与2023年全国住院医师匹配计划的数据进行比对。还利用了《美国新闻与世界报道》对顶级外科培训项目的排名。
共有2803个普通外科培训名额,其中1597个(57%)位于目前已实施反LGBTQ立法的州。245个(9%)培训名额在没有此类立法但目前正在考虑反LGBTQ立法的州。在排名前20的住院医师项目中,11个(55%)位于有反LGBTQ立法的州。在附属专科中,综合血管外科、整形外科和胸外科的外科培训岗位分别有50个(54%)、118个(57%)和24个(49%)位于目前已实施反LGBTQ立法的州。总体而言,63%的专科 fellowship 机会位于有反LGBTQ立法的州。
大多数研究生外科教育在有反LGBTQ立法的州进行,这可能会限制重视LGBTQ权利保护的人的住院医师选择。