Nelson Jennifer S, Harrington Lesley, Holland Emily, Cardoso Hugo F V
University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Brandon University, Brandon, Manitoba, Canada.
Am J Biol Anthropol. 2025 Jan;186(1):e25047. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.25047.
Many human growth studies note a trend of differential variation in limb segment lengths, where distal elements show greater variability than their proximal counterparts. This has been attributed to their developmental sequence, where bones further from the head develop later and are more impacted by fluctuating growth conditions. We aimed to explore limb dimensions within this framework, known as the laws of developmental direction, in children (0.09-11.75 years) from a documented skeletal collection of low socioeconomic status.
Z-scores were generated for diaphyseal length measurements of six limb bones. Differences between mean z-score values of the limbs, as well as of the proximal and distal segments of each limb, were assessed using paired samples t-tests.
The lower limb was significantly more stunted in growth relative to the upper limb (p ≤ 0.001), as was the distal segment of the upper limb relative to the proximal segment (p ≤ 0.001). In contrast, the distal segment of the lower limb was significantly less stunted in growth relative to the proximal segment (p ≤ 0.001).
The findings of increased sensitivity in the lower limb relative to the upper limb and in the distal segment of the upper limb relative to its proximal segment are consistent with the laws of developmental direction. However, the finding of greater sensitivity in the proximal segment of the lower limb relative to the distal segment does not align with the theorized developmental gradient. These results reveal the complexity of human growth and developmental plasticity in response to biocultural factors.
许多人类生长研究指出肢体节段长度存在差异变化趋势,即远端部分比其近端对应部分表现出更大的变异性。这归因于它们的发育顺序,离头部较远的骨骼发育较晚,且更容易受到生长条件波动的影响。我们旨在从一个记录在案的低社会经济地位骨骼样本中,探索0.09至11.75岁儿童在这个被称为发育方向定律的框架内的肢体尺寸情况。
对六根肢体骨骼的骨干长度测量值生成Z分数。使用配对样本t检验评估四肢以及每只肢体近端和远端节段的平均Z分数值之间的差异。
与上肢相比,下肢生长发育明显更为迟缓(p≤0.001),上肢远端节段相对于近端节段也是如此(p≤0.001)。相比之下,下肢远端节段相对于近端节段生长发育迟缓程度明显更低(p≤0.001)。
下肢相对于上肢以及上肢远端节段相对于近端节段敏感性增加的研究结果与发育方向定律一致。然而,下肢近端节段相对于远端节段敏感性更高这一发现与理论上的发育梯度不一致。这些结果揭示了人类生长以及对生物文化因素反应的发育可塑性的复杂性。