Bozzetti Federico
Freelance Surgeon Oncologist, Residenza Querce, Milanodue, 20054 Segrate, Italy.
Curr Oncol. 2024 Dec 1;31(12):7631-7646. doi: 10.3390/curroncol31120563.
The purpose of this review is the analysis of the literature concerning the effects of physical exercise in cancer patients undergoing medical oncologic treatment. Papers were retrieved from the scrutiny of 15 reviews/meta-analyses published in the last 2 years, which, however, pooled different populations of patients (surgical and medical patients, receiving or not an oncologic therapy, harboring a cancer, or being survivors).
We reviewed the data of 35 RCTs on the use of physical exercise in cancer patients, distinguishing well-nourished from malnourished patients. The conclusions of our study are the following: No major difference between well-nourished and malnourished patients as regards compliance/adherence with physical exercise and outcomes. Compliance with physical exercise was reported in about 70% of the studies. Compared with a control group receiving the usual care, in patients who practiced physical exercise, a benefit in some parameters of physical function and quality of life and lean body mass (LBM) was reported in 61%, 47%, and 12%, respectively, of the studies in non-malnourished patients, and in 50%, 100%, and 36%, respectively, of the studies in malnourished patients. The benefit in LBM was more frequently reported in weight-losing patients. There was no strict association among the results of different outcomes (muscle function vs. quality of life vs. LBM). There are still some ill-defined issues, including the optimal physical regimen (with some authors favoring high-intensity interval training and resistance) and the place of exercising (patients usually preferring home exercises, which, however, have been proved less efficacious).
本综述的目的是分析有关体育锻炼对接受医学肿瘤治疗的癌症患者影响的文献。通过查阅过去两年发表的15篇综述/荟萃分析检索到相关论文,然而,这些综述/荟萃分析纳入了不同患者群体(手术患者和内科患者,接受或未接受肿瘤治疗,患癌患者或癌症幸存者)。
我们回顾了35项关于癌症患者体育锻炼的随机对照试验数据,区分了营养良好和营养不良的患者。我们的研究结论如下:营养良好和营养不良患者在体育锻炼的依从性/坚持性及结果方面无重大差异。约70%的研究报告了体育锻炼的依从性。与接受常规护理的对照组相比,进行体育锻炼的患者中,非营养不良患者的研究分别有61%、47%和12%报告在某些身体功能参数、生活质量和瘦体重(LBM)方面有获益,营养不良患者的研究分别有50%、100%和36%报告有获益。LBM方面的获益在体重减轻的患者中报告得更频繁。不同结果(肌肉功能与生活质量与LBM)的结果之间没有严格关联。仍有一些定义不明确的问题,包括最佳体育锻炼方案(一些作者倾向于高强度间歇训练和阻力训练)以及锻炼场所(患者通常更喜欢在家锻炼,然而事实证明在家锻炼效果较差)。