Ryan Lisa, Daly Ed, Hunzinger Katherine
Department of Sport, Exercise and Nutrition, School of Science and Computing, Atlantic Technological University, Dublin Rd., H91 T8NW Galway, Ireland.
Department of Exercise Science, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA 19144, USA.
J Funct Morphol Kinesiol. 2024 Dec 18;9(4):277. doi: 10.3390/jfmk9040277.
Collision-sport athletes, such as rugby players, are at risk of sport-related concussion (SRC). Women are known to be at higher risk of SRC and may experience more severe and chronic symptomology than men. Knowledge of the factors that affect a player's disclosure of their concussive symptoms could help to inform strategies to improve compliance with reporting and management of head injuries. The aim of this study was to investigate the factors that may impact women rugby players' disclosure of a concussion. : Twenty-eight adult (≥18 years of age) elite and semi-elite women rugby players from the UK and Ireland ( = 17) and the United States ( = 11) were interviewed on their playing background and SRC experience in women's rugby via one-on-one interviews (UK and Ireland) or an online questionnaire (US). : SRC data were analysed inductively using a thematic analysis approach to determine the potential reasons for SRC non-disclosure in women's rugby. Four main themes were identified which may influence a player's SRC non-disclosure: 1. women rugby players are self-managing SRC; 2. work-related concerns impact on SRC disclosure; 3. players and support staff lack knowledge on SRC management; and 4. poor internal and external communication affect the support players receive when injured. The findings were consistent across players from different countries. This research highlighted several factors that may impact on women rugby players' disclosure of SRC regardless of country of origin (UK, Ireland, or US) and access to concussion care. Coaches and management teams should be aware of these reasons, which may enhance how they discuss and manage concussion. There is a clear need for further education on concussion for players and support staff and for strategies to create environments where women can openly discuss their concussion concerns.
从事碰撞性运动的运动员,如橄榄球运动员,有遭受与运动相关的脑震荡(SRC)的风险。众所周知,女性遭受SRC的风险更高,并且可能比男性经历更严重和更慢性的症状。了解影响运动员披露其脑震荡症状的因素,有助于制定策略,以提高对头部损伤报告和管理的依从性。本研究的目的是调查可能影响女性橄榄球运动员脑震荡披露的因素。来自英国、爱尔兰(n = 17)和美国(n = 11)的28名成年(≥18岁)精英和半精英女性橄榄球运动员,通过一对一访谈(英国和爱尔兰)或在线问卷(美国),就她们在女子橄榄球方面的比赛背景和SRC经历接受了访谈。采用主题分析方法对SRC数据进行归纳分析,以确定女子橄榄球中不披露SRC的潜在原因。确定了四个可能影响运动员不披露SRC的主要主题:1. 女性橄榄球运动员自行管理SRC;2. 与工作相关的担忧影响SRC披露;3. 运动员和支持人员缺乏SRC管理知识;4. 内部和外部沟通不畅影响运动员受伤时获得的支持。不同国家的运动员得出的结果一致。这项研究强调了几个可能影响女性橄榄球运动员SRC披露的因素,无论其原籍国(英国、爱尔兰或美国)以及获得脑震荡护理的情况如何。教练和管理团队应该了解这些原因,这可能会改善他们讨论和管理脑震荡的方式。显然需要为运动员和支持人员提供关于脑震荡的进一步教育,并制定策略,营造女性能够公开讨论其脑震荡担忧的环境。