Van Zyl-Cillié Maria Magdalena, Bührmann Jacoba H, Blignaut Alwiena J, Demirtas Derya, Coetzee Siedine K
Faculty of Engineering, North-West University, 11 Hoffman Street, Potchefstroom, South Africa.
Faculty of Behavioural, Management and Social Sciences, University of Twente, 5 Drienerlolaan, 7522 NB, Enschede, The Netherlands.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Dec 31;24(1):1665. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-12184-5.
The demand for quality healthcare is rising worldwide, and nurses in South Africa are under pressure to provide care with limited resources. This demanding work environment leads to burnout and exhaustion among nurses. Understanding the specific factors leading to these issues is critical for adequately supporting nurses and informing policymakers. Currently, little is known about the unique factors associated with burnout and emotional exhaustion among nurses in South Africa. Furthermore, whether these factors can be predicted using demographic data alone is unclear. Machine learning has recently been proven to solve complex problems and accurately predict outcomes in medical settings. In this study, supervised machine learning models were developed to identify the factors that most strongly predict nurses reporting feelings of burnout and experiencing emotional exhaustion.
The PyCaret 3.3 package was used to develop classification machine learning models on 1165 collected survey responses from nurses across South Africa in medical-surgical units. The models were evaluated on their accuracy score, Area Under the Curve (AUC) score and confusion matrix performance. Additionally, the accuracy score of models using demographic data alone was compared to the full survey data models. The features with the highest predictive power were extracted from both the full survey data and demographic data models for comparison. Descriptive statistical analysis was used to analyse survey data according to the highest predictive factors.
The gradient booster classifier (GBC) model had the highest accuracy score for predicting both self-reported feelings of burnout (75.8%) and emotional exhaustion (76.8%) from full survey data. For demographic data alone, the accuracy score was 60.4% and 68.5%, respectively, for predicting self-reported feelings of burnout and emotional exhaustion. Fatigue was the factor with the highest predictive power for self-reported feelings of burnout and emotional exhaustion. Nursing staff's confidence in management was the second highest predictor for feelings of burnout whereas management who listens to employees was the second highest predictor for emotional exhaustion.
Supervised machine learning models can accurately predict self-reported feelings of burnout or emotional exhaustion among nurses in South Africa from full survey data but not from demographic data alone. The models identified fatigue rating, confidence in management and management who listens to employees as the most important factors to address to prevent these issues among nurses in South Africa.
全球对优质医疗保健的需求不断上升,南非的护士面临着在资源有限的情况下提供护理的压力。这种苛刻的工作环境导致护士出现职业倦怠和疲惫。了解导致这些问题的具体因素对于充分支持护士并为政策制定者提供信息至关重要。目前,对于南非护士职业倦怠和情绪疲惫相关的独特因素知之甚少。此外,仅使用人口统计数据能否预测这些因素尚不清楚。机器学习最近已被证明可以解决复杂问题并准确预测医疗环境中的结果。在本研究中,开发了监督机器学习模型,以识别最能强烈预测护士报告职业倦怠感和经历情绪疲惫的因素。
使用PyCaret 3.3软件包,基于从南非医疗外科病房的护士收集的1165份调查回复开发分类机器学习模型。对模型的准确率得分、曲线下面积(AUC)得分和混淆矩阵性能进行评估。此外,将仅使用人口统计数据的模型的准确率得分与完整调查数据模型进行比较。从完整调查数据模型和人口统计数据模型中提取预测能力最高的特征进行比较。使用描述性统计分析根据最高预测因素分析调查数据。
梯度提升分类器(GBC)模型在从完整调查数据预测自我报告的职业倦怠感(75.8%)和情绪疲惫(76.8%)方面具有最高的准确率得分。仅对于人口统计数据,预测自我报告的职业倦怠感和情绪疲惫的准确率得分分别为60.4%和68.5%。疲劳是自我报告的职业倦怠感和情绪疲惫的预测能力最高的因素。护理人员对管理层的信心是职业倦怠感的第二高预测因素,而倾听员工意见的管理层是情绪疲惫的第二高预测因素。
监督机器学习模型可以从完整调查数据中准确预测南非护士自我报告的职业倦怠感或情绪疲惫,但不能仅从人口统计数据中预测。这些模型确定疲劳评分、对管理层的信心以及倾听员工意见的管理层是解决南非护士中这些问题需要关注的最重要因素。