Alghilan Maryam A, Ui Haq Ikram
Department of Restorative and Prosthetic Dental Sciences, King Saud Bin AbdulAziz University for Health Sciences, King Abdullah International Medical Research, Riyadh, SAU.
College of Dentistry, King Saud Bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Riyadh, SAU.
Cureus. 2024 Nov 30;16(11):e74830. doi: 10.7759/cureus.74830. eCollection 2024 Nov.
Erosive tooth wear (ETW) is a prevalent oral condition with varying etiology, including erosion, abrasion, abfraction, and attrition. It is reported in the literature in different nomenclatures, hindering the ability to identify the emerging trends and influential scholarly works and bodies within this field. Using a bibliometric analysis approach, this study aims to evaluate the trends, themes, and productivity of the research on ETW condition while respecting its different terminologies. The Web of Science database was utilized to obtain the publication records on ETW to implement a retrospective bibliometric study. The data were retrieved on September 10, 2024, with the search terms "Dental erosion" OR "enamel erosion" OR "erosive tooth" OR "dental abrasion" OR "tooth abrasion" OR "toothbrush abrasion" OR "enamel abrasion" OR "non-carious cervical lesion" OR "non carious cervical lesion" OR "abfraction" OR "abfractions" OR "Tooth wear" OR "erosive tooth wear". We identified 6,069 records, and after applying inclusion/exclusion criteria, we removed 679, and the remaining 5,390 papers were considered for the analysis. The bibliometric indicators include types and accessibility modes, year of publications with citations, publishing sources, most contributing countries, institutions, authorship patterns, top authors, keywords, and the characteristics of the 15 most cited articles were examined. For the data analysis, Microsoft Excel (v.16; Microsoft® Corp., Redmond, WA), VOSviewer (v.1.6.10; https://www.vosviewer.com), and Statistical Product and Service Solutions (SPSS, v.27; IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Armonk, NY) software were utilized. The outcome illustrated that 5,390 papers on ETW were contributed by the authors of 127 countries and published in 1,112 journals between 1945 and 2023. The published the most papers (n=290), while the had the most impactful papers (54.91 citations/paper). Authors from 3,904 institutions participated. The University of São Paulo became the most productive institution with 336 papers, while the University of Bristol's papers had the maximum citation impact (55.32 citations/paper). About 81.49% of the total authors had produced one paper each. The percentage of average authors for each paper was found to be 4.41, and David Bartlett was the most productive author. The most cited top 15 papers got an average of 297.26 citations per paper. About 77% of research on ETW was published in the last two decades. This bibliometric evaluation provides direction for future research and data regarding the present state of research on ETW.
侵蚀性牙齿磨损(ETW)是一种常见的口腔疾病,病因多样,包括酸蚀、磨损、楔状缺损和磨耗。文献中对其有不同的命名,这妨碍了人们识别该领域的新兴趋势以及有影响力的学术著作和团体。本研究采用文献计量分析方法,旨在评估关于ETW疾病的研究趋势、主题和产出,同时考虑到其不同的术语。利用科学网数据库获取ETW的出版记录,以进行回顾性文献计量研究。数据于2024年9月10日检索,检索词为“牙齿酸蚀”或“牙釉质酸蚀”或“侵蚀性牙齿”或“牙齿磨损”或“牙刷磨损”或“牙釉质磨损”或“非龋性颈部病变”或“楔状缺损”或“牙齿磨损”或“侵蚀性牙齿磨损”。我们识别出6069条记录,在应用纳入/排除标准后,剔除了679条,其余5390篇论文用于分析。文献计量指标包括类型和获取方式、带被引次数的出版年份、出版来源、贡献最大的国家、机构、作者模式、顶尖作者、关键词,并对被引次数最多的15篇文章的特征进行了研究。数据分析使用了微软Excel(版本16;微软公司,华盛顿州雷德蒙德)、VOSviewer(版本1.6.10;https://www.vosviewer.com)和统计产品与服务解决方案(SPSS,版本27;IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows,纽约州阿蒙克)软件。结果表明,1945年至2023年间,来自127个国家的作者发表了5390篇关于ETW的论文,发表在1112种期刊上。[此处缺失具体国家名称]发表的论文最多(n = 290),而[此处缺失具体国家名称]的论文影响力最大(每篇论文被引54.91次)。来自3904个机构的作者参与其中。圣保罗大学成为产出最多的机构,有336篇论文,而布里斯托尔大学的论文被引影响最大(每篇论文被引55.32次)。约81.49%的作者每人发表了一篇论文。每篇论文的平均作者人数为4.41人,大卫·巴特利特是产出最多的作者。被引次数最多的前15篇论文平均每篇被引297.26次。关于ETW的研究约77%是在过去二十年发表的。这项文献计量评估为未来研究提供了方向,并提供了有关ETW研究现状的数据。