Klootwijk Larissa, Zeyrek Eva, Njuguna Festus, Ket Johannes C F, Mostert Saskia, Kaspers Gertjan
Emma Children's Hospital, Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Princess Máxima Center for Pediatric Oncology, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Int J Health Plann Manage. 2025 Mar;40(2):474-493. doi: 10.1002/hpm.3890. Epub 2025 Jan 3.
Sub-Saharan Africa is facing a severe crisis in human resources for health. Primary healthcare is the most affected. This problem is aggravated by absenteeism, implying that healthcare workers are absent on duty during scheduled working hours. This scoping review maps existing literature on absenteeism among primary healthcare workers in Sub-Saharan Africa.
This scoping review complies with the Population Concept Context guidelines of Arksey and O'Malley and the PRISMA 2020 checklist. A literature search (Medline, Embase, Scopus, Africa Index Medicus) was performed from inception until December 2023 in collaboration with a medical information specialist. Peer-reviewed English-published literature was considered. Two independent reviewers screened titles, abstracts, and full-texts.
Twenty-four studies were included from 7 of 46 Sub-Saharan countries (15%). Prevalence of absenteeism varied from 14% to 49%. Causes at individual and health-system levels were explored in 16 studies (67%) and included physician dual practices (75%), low wages (69%), and insufficient supervision (56%). Consequences at the healthcare worker and patient level were described in 14 studies (58%) and included hindered/delayed access to care (64%), high workload (29%), and increased treatment costs when patients are forced to attend private facilities (22%). Recommendations to address absenteeism were provided in 18 studies (75%) and included regular supervision (33%), performance-based rewards/punishments (33%), and augmented salaries (33%).
Absenteeism is highly prevalent among primary healthcare workers in Sub-Sahara Africa. Its adverse impact on both healthcare workers and patients is profound. The complexity of different individual and health system causal factors shows that a multifactorial approach to address absenteeism is warranted.
撒哈拉以南非洲地区正面临着严重的卫生人力资源危机。初级卫生保健受到的影响最为严重。旷工现象加剧了这一问题,这意味着医护人员在规定的工作时间内缺勤。本综述梳理了撒哈拉以南非洲地区初级卫生保健工作者旷工现象的现有文献。
本综述遵循阿克西和奥马利的“人群概念背景”指南以及PRISMA 2020清单。与医学信息专家合作,从数据库建立至2023年12月进行了文献检索(检索数据库包括Medline、Embase、Scopus、非洲医学索引)。纳入经同行评审的英文发表文献。两名独立评审员对标题、摘要和全文进行筛选。
从46个撒哈拉以南国家中的7个国家(15%)纳入了24项研究。旷工率从14%到49%不等。16项研究(67%)探讨了个人层面和卫生系统层面的原因,包括医生兼职(75%)、低工资(69%)和监督不足(56%)。14项研究(58%)描述了对医护人员和患者层面的后果,包括获得医疗服务受阻/延迟(64%)、高工作量(29%)以及患者被迫前往私立医疗机构时治疗成本增加(22%)。18项研究(75%)提供了应对旷工现象的建议,包括定期监督(33%)、基于绩效的奖惩(33%)和提高工资(33%)。
旷工现象在撒哈拉以南非洲地区的初级卫生保健工作者中非常普遍。其对医护人员和患者的不利影响都很深远。不同的个人和卫生系统因果因素的复杂性表明,有必要采取多因素方法来解决旷工问题。