Swanson Eric
From the Swanson Center, Leawood, KS.
Ann Plast Surg. 2025 Feb 1;94(2):250-256. doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000004155. Epub 2024 Nov 19.
Electromagnetic treatments have recently been combined with radiofrequency to reduce the fat layer and simultaneously increase muscle thickness. Studies report treatment efficacy, using photographs and imaging methods.
A literature review was conducted. Measurement data were tabulated. The EmSculpt Neo device (BTL Industries, Boston, MA) was used in all studies.
Seven studies evaluated the fat thickness and muscle thickness using either ultrasound (1 study) or magnetic resonance imaging methods (6 studies). The abdomen was treated in 2 studies. The other studies treated the lateral thighs, flanks, buttocks, inner thighs, and upper arms. The mean reduction in fat thickness was 8.0 mm, and the mean increase in muscle thickness was 5.5 mm. All 7 studies were authored by BTL medical advisors. Measured changes were likely within the margin of error and of questionable clinical relevance. Few adverse events were reported.
Photographs were frequently not standardized, showing changes in treated areas, but unexplained changes in nontreated areas as well. The magnetic resonance imaging scans were affected by differing levels of the axial slice. Measured changes were incremental and likely not indicative of a true treatment effect. The scientific basis for efficacy is tenuous, both for fat reduction and muscle hypertrophy.
A scientific evaluation of the results fails to produce reliable evidence of a clinically meaningful result for this combination energy-based treatment. Financial conflict is a major factor. Liposuction remains the gold standard.
电磁治疗最近已与射频相结合,以减少脂肪层并同时增加肌肉厚度。研究使用照片和成像方法报告了治疗效果。
进行了文献综述。将测量数据制成表格。所有研究均使用了EmSculpt Neo设备(BTL Industries,波士顿,马萨诸塞州)。
七项研究使用超声(1项研究)或磁共振成像方法(6项研究)评估了脂肪厚度和肌肉厚度。两项研究治疗了腹部。其他研究治疗了大腿外侧、侧腹、臀部、大腿内侧和上臂。脂肪厚度的平均减少量为8.0毫米,肌肉厚度的平均增加量为5.5毫米。所有七项研究均由BTL医学顾问撰写。测量到的变化可能在误差范围内,且临床相关性存疑。报告的不良事件很少。
照片通常不规范,显示了治疗区域的变化,但未治疗区域也出现了无法解释的变化。磁共振成像扫描受到轴向切片不同水平的影响。测量到的变化是渐进的,可能并不表明真正的治疗效果。无论是减脂还是肌肉肥大,疗效的科学依据都很薄弱。
对结果的科学评估未能产生可靠证据证明这种基于能量的联合治疗具有临床意义的结果。经济利益冲突是一个主要因素。抽脂仍然是金标准。