Zeman J, Zeman J, Korpa P, Matějka T, Zeman P, Matějka J
Klinika ortopedie a traumatologie pohybového ústrojí Fakultní nemocnice Plzeň.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2024;91(6):339-347. doi: 10.55095/ACHOT2024/044.
Intraarticular fractures of the distal femur rank among the most severe musculoskeletal injuries. Various treatment options, such as plate osteosynthesis or retrograde nailing, can be employed. This study aims to evaluate the clinical outcomes and complications of intraarticular distal femoral fractures treated with retrograde femoral nail, with particular emphasis on C3 fractures.
Between January 2016 and January 2023, 18 AO/33.C3 fractures were treated with a retrograde femoral nail. Of these, two were classified as 33.C1, eight as 33.C2 and eight as 33.C3. Twelve of the fractures were open. After the initial treatment and stabilizing the patient's overall condition, we proceeded with the definitive osteosynthesis. The first phase involved open reduction and fixation using individual screws to reconstruct the articular surface. The second phase consisted in retrograde nailing with correction of the length, axis and rotation of the femur. The evaluation criteria included: complication rate, number of revisions, knee range of motion, mechanical axis and length of the lower extremity, progression of gonarthrosis, pain level, need of walking support, Lysholm and Tegner Activity Score for functional outcome.
Overall, we evaluated the complications and the outcomes of 12 patients (13 fractures). Of these, 8 patients experienced some kind of postoperative complications, primarily insufficient healing or nonunion, which were managed through revision surgery. Plate reosteosynthesis was used in 2 patients who were then excluded from the final clinical evaluation. No cases of deep infection or deep vein thrombosis were reported and no patient required total knee replacement. Seven AO/33.C3 fractures were individually evaluated. The average knee range of motion was nearly 0-93°, maximum flexion was 120°. On average, the lower extremity was 1.6 cm shorter and 7.3° varus to the mechanical axis. Only little progression of gonarthrosis was observed along with low levels of pain. The Lysholm Score ranged between 52 and 84 points (averaging 73.1). The mean Tegner Activity Score was 3.4. All results showed adequate improvement in 33.C2 and 33.C1 groups.
The retrograde femoral nail demonstrates several advantages over the locking compression plate, particularly in biomechanical aspects. Various clinical studies have reported superior outcomes in terms of healing, complication rate, blood loss and functional outcome. Our study findings align with some of those international studies, particularly in the rate of infectious complications (0%), mean Lysholm Score (79.3 p.) and Tegner Activity Score (4.1). On the other hand, we observed a higher rate of revision surgery (53.8 %), mainly due to evaluating 33.C fractures only. The main advantage of this method lies in complete visualization, leading to better reconstruction of the articular surface coupled with excellent biomechanical properties of the intramedullary nail.
Intraarticular distal femoral fractures pose significant challenges to treatment and frequently lead to permanent damage. The primary treatment goals involve achieving anatomical reposition of the articular surface, stable osteosynthesis, correction of the femoral length and axis and early rehabilitation. Our study demonstrates good clinical outcomes with a relatively low rate of complications. Patients are capable of walking without pain, achieving a good range of motion, returning to their occupations and becoming self-sufficient. Moreover, there were no infectious complications and no significant progression of gonarthrosis.
retrograde femoral nail, intraarticular distal femoral fracture, functional outcome, complication rate.
股骨远端关节内骨折是最严重的肌肉骨骼损伤之一。可采用多种治疗方法,如钢板内固定或逆行髓内钉固定。本研究旨在评估逆行股骨钉治疗股骨远端关节内骨折的临床疗效和并发症,尤其关注C3型骨折。
2016年1月至2023年1月期间,18例AO/33.C3型骨折采用逆行股骨钉治疗。其中,2例为33.C1型,8例为33.C2型,8例为33.C3型。12例骨折为开放性骨折。在初始治疗并稳定患者整体状况后,进行确定性内固定。第一阶段包括切开复位并用单独螺钉固定以重建关节面。第二阶段为逆行髓内钉固定并纠正股骨长度、轴线和旋转。评估标准包括:并发症发生率、翻修次数、膝关节活动范围、机械轴线和下肢长度、膝关节骨关节炎进展情况、疼痛程度、行走辅助需求、Lysholm评分和Tegner活动评分以评估功能结果。
总体而言,我们评估了12例患者(13处骨折)的并发症和结果。其中,8例患者出现某种术后并发症,主要是愈合不足或骨不连,通过翻修手术处理。2例患者采用钢板再次内固定,随后被排除在最终临床评估之外。未报告深部感染或深静脉血栓形成病例,且无患者需要全膝关节置换。对7例AO/33.C3型骨折进行了单独评估。平均膝关节活动范围接近0 - 93°,最大屈曲为120°。平均而言,下肢短缩1.6 cm,相对于机械轴线内翻7.3°。仅观察到膝关节骨关节炎有轻微进展,疼痛程度较低。Lysholm评分在52至84分之间(平均73.1分)。平均Tegner活动评分为3.4分。所有结果显示33.C2和33.C1组有充分改善。
逆行股骨钉相对于锁定加压钢板具有若干优势,特别是在生物力学方面。各种临床研究报告在愈合、并发症发生率、失血量和功能结果方面有更好的疗效。我们的研究结果与一些国际研究一致,特别是在感染性并发症发生率(0%)、平均Lysholm评分(79.3分)和Tegner活动评分(4.1分)方面。另一方面,我们观察到较高的翻修手术率(53.8%),主要是因为仅评估了33.C型骨折。该方法的主要优势在于完全可视化,从而能更好地重建关节面,同时髓内钉具有优异的生物力学性能。
股骨远端关节内骨折给治疗带来重大挑战,常导致永久性损伤。主要治疗目标包括实现关节面的解剖复位、稳定的内固定、纠正股骨长度和轴线以及早期康复。我们的研究显示临床疗效良好,并发症发生率相对较低。患者能够无痛行走,获得良好的活动范围,恢复工作并实现自理。此外,未出现感染性并发症,膝关节骨关节炎也无明显进展。
逆行股骨钉;股骨远端关节内骨折;功能结果;并发症发生率