Jarry Cristián, Varas Cohen Julián
Experimental Surgery and Simulation Center, Faculty of Medicine, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile; Colorectal Surgery Unit, Department of Digestive Surgery, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile. Electronic address: https://twitter.com/@cjarryt.
Experimental Surgery and Simulation Center, Faculty of Medicine, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile; Department of Digestive Surgery, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile.
Surgery. 2025 Apr;180:109097. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2024.109097. Epub 2025 Jan 9.
Distance and remote simulation have emerged as vital tools in modern surgical education, offering solutions to challenges such as limited operating hours, growing clinical demands, and the need for consistent, high-quality training. This review examines the benefits, limitations, and strategies for implementing sustainable distance simulation, structured around 3 foundational pillars: (1) effective hardware and infrastructure, including simulators and realistic scenarios that enable trainees to develop essential skills; (2) validated training programs grounded in educational theory with a clear focus on skill transfer and predictive validity; and (3) timely access to effective feedback. Distance simulation permits adaptable, scalable training environments, but the addition of remote and deferred feedback has further broadened its impact, helping to overcome the challenges posed by faculty availability and clinician time constraints. Remote-asynchronous feedback not only makes teaching time more efficient but also allows instructors to organize their time flexibly, maximizing their impact. Furthermore, web-based feedback oriented platforms facilitate the creation of a sustainable teaching network through train-the-trainer initiatives, enabling near-peer and nonclinical experts to provide standardized, high-quality teaching. This scalable model reduces the reliance on senior faculty, building a culture of mentorship and support within the surgical education community. In addition, distance simulation platforms are increasingly incorporating artificial intelligence-enhanced assessment tools capable of detecting errors, analyzing procedural steps, and generating automated feedback. Integrating artificial intelligence into innovative simulation modalities not only enhances access to quality feedback but also could provide deeper insights into the learning process, as learners progress through these enriched learning curves. Growing evidence shows how tools for sustainable distance simulation can positively impact education at multiple levels, benefiting undergraduate and postgraduate students, residents, and faculty across a spectrum of skills from basic tasks to complex surgical procedures. Moreover, its applications extend beyond simulated environments, providing frameworks that can be adapted to teach real surgical performance in clinical settings. As surgical education evolves, distance simulation demonstrates immense value in supporting accessible, high-quality training, particularly in resource-limited environments.
远程模拟已成为现代外科教育中的重要工具,为应对诸如手术时间有限、临床需求不断增加以及需要持续高质量培训等挑战提供了解决方案。本综述探讨了实施可持续远程模拟的益处、局限性和策略,围绕3个基础支柱展开:(1)有效的硬件和基础设施,包括模拟器和逼真的场景,使学员能够培养基本技能;(2)基于教育理论的经过验证的培训计划,明确侧重于技能转移和预测效度;(3)及时获得有效的反馈。远程模拟允许灵活、可扩展的培训环境,但增加远程和延迟反馈进一步扩大了其影响,有助于克服师资可用性和临床医生时间限制带来的挑战。远程异步反馈不仅提高了教学时间的效率,还使教师能够灵活安排时间,最大限度地发挥其影响。此外,基于网络的反馈导向平台通过培训培训师计划促进了可持续教学网络的创建,使近同伴和非临床专家能够提供标准化、高质量的教学。这种可扩展模式减少了对外科资深教员的依赖,在外科教育界营造了一种指导和支持的文化。此外,远程模拟平台越来越多地纳入能够检测错误、分析手术步骤并生成自动反馈的人工智能增强评估工具。将人工智能整合到创新的模拟模式中,不仅可以增加获得高质量反馈的机会,还可以在学习者经历这些丰富的学习曲线时,对学习过程提供更深入的见解。越来越多的证据表明,可持续远程模拟工具如何能够在多个层面上对教育产生积极影响,使本科和研究生、住院医师以及教员在从基本任务到复杂外科手术的一系列技能方面受益。此外,其应用超出了模拟环境,提供了可适用于在临床环境中教授实际手术操作的框架。随着外科教育的发展,远程模拟在支持可及的高质量培训方面显示出巨大价值,尤其是在资源有限的环境中。
Surgery. 2025-4
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-1
J Educ Teach Emerg Med. 2020-4-15
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-1