Abahuje Egide, Tuyishime Eugène, Alayande Barnabas T
Northwestern Quality Improvement & Research in Surgery, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL.
College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Rwanda, Kigali, Rwanda.
Surgery. 2025 Apr;180:109050. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2024.109050. Epub 2024 Dec 30.
The traditional apprenticeship model of "see one, do one, teach one" is no longer considered the most effective approach for training surgical trainees. Key factors such as patient safety, increasing trainee numbers, and clinician workload pose significant challenges to surgical training. These pressures have led to the adoption of simulation-based education as an effective adjunct to clinical experience when training future surgeons. The goal of simulation is to provide a controlled, real-life-like environment where trainees can practice and enhance both technical and behavioral or "nontechnical skills" through deliberate practice and structured feedback. In addition to improving psychomotor skills, simulation can also allow health care providers to "rehearse" rare or complex surgical procedures and should also be leveraged to teach behavioral skills such as communication, teamwork, and decision-making. Telesimulation, which is the use of the internet to connect simulation instructors and trainees in remote locations for simulation-based medical education along with virtual and augmented reality, offers cost-effective alternatives to physical simulation spaces. Although simulation-based education is widely used in high-income countries for surgical training, it remains underused in low- and middle-income countries, where surgical education still relies largely on didactic methods, bedside teaching, and intraoperative learning. As a result, a significant opportunity is being missed to use simulation as an educational tool in low- and middle-income countries. The barriers to adopting and scaling up simulation-based education in these regions include the absence of context-specific simulation curricula, competing clinical priorities, limited resources for capacity building, a lack of skilled simulation instructors, and inadequate financial support to establish, equip, and maintain simulation centers staffed by trained experts. Collaborations between academic institutions in high-income countries and low- and middle-income countries have helped overcome some of these obstacles. These partnerships have facilitated the training of local faculty to use simulation effectively for teaching clinical skills and the acquisition of grants to build simulation centers, purchase affordable simulation equipment, and hire personnel.
“看一个,做一个,教一个”的传统学徒模式不再被认为是培训外科实习生的最有效方法。患者安全、实习生数量增加和临床医生工作量等关键因素给外科培训带来了重大挑战。这些压力导致采用基于模拟的教育作为培训未来外科医生时临床经验的有效辅助手段。模拟的目标是提供一个可控的、逼真的环境,让实习生通过刻意练习和结构化反馈来练习和提高技术及行为或“非技术技能”。除了提高心理运动技能外,模拟还可以让医疗保健提供者“演练”罕见或复杂的外科手术,还应用于教授沟通、团队合作和决策等行为技能。远程模拟是利用互联网将偏远地区的模拟教员和实习生连接起来进行基于模拟的医学教育,以及虚拟和增强现实,它为实体模拟空间提供了经济高效的替代方案。尽管基于模拟的教育在高收入国家广泛用于外科培训,但在低收入和中等收入国家仍未得到充分利用,这些国家的外科教育仍然主要依赖于说教方法、床边教学和术中学习。因此,在低收入和中等收入国家错失了将模拟用作教育工具的重大机会。在这些地区采用和扩大基于模拟的教育的障碍包括缺乏针对具体情况的模拟课程、相互竞争的临床重点、能力建设资源有限、缺乏熟练的模拟教员以及缺乏资金支持来建立、配备和维护由训练有素的专家组成的模拟中心。高收入国家的学术机构与低收入和中等收入国家之间的合作有助于克服其中一些障碍。这些伙伴关系促进了对当地教员的培训,使其能够有效地利用模拟教授临床技能,并获得赠款以建立模拟中心、购买经济实惠的模拟设备和雇佣人员。