Liu H L, Wang L, Wang X, Tian L T, Hao Q S, Qiu F B, Zhou B
Department of Hepatobiliary and Pancreatic Surgery & Retroperitoneal Tumor Surgery, Affiliated Hospital of Qingdao University, Qingdao 266001, China.
Operating Theater, Affiliated Hospital of Qingdao University, Qingdao 266001, China.
Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2025 Feb 1;63(2):147-152. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112139-20240918-00428.
To explore the efficacy of robotic-assisted retroperitoneal benign tumor resection and to analyze its learning curve. This is a retrospective case series study. The data of patients who underwent robotic-assisted retroperitoneal benign tumor resection from August 2015 to February 2023 at the Department of Retroperitoneal Tumor Surgery was analyzed retrospectively. There were 24 males and 45 females, with an age of (46.3±10.6) years (range: 19 to 76 years). The perioperative data, postoperative pathological results, and follow-up data were recorded. The cumulative sum (CUSUM) method was used to analyze the robotic system setup time and operative time to plot the learning curve. A linear regression model was applied to determine the best-fit curve, selecting the model with the highest R² value. Based on the vertex of the learning curve for surgical time, the patients were divided into a learning group and a mastery group. The general data and perioperative conditions of the two groups were compared. Independent sample -tests, Mann-Whitney tests, and tests were used for comparisons. All 69 patients successfully completed the surgery without intraoperative complications. The diameter of tumors was (49.7±18.6) mm (range: 16 to 131 mm). The setup time for the robotic surgical system was (35.3±9.8) minutes (range: 20 to 61 minutes); the surgical time was (169.2±36.5) minutes (range: 70 to 305 minutes); intraoperative blood loss ((IQR)) was 10.0 (15.0) ml (range: 2.0 to 200.0 ml). The tumors in 32 patients (46.4%) were adherent to major blood vessels. All patients were discharged without complications. The follow-up period lasted until February 2024, and no patients required reoperation, readmission, or died due to retroperitoneal benign tumors. There were no severe long-term complications, and no radiological evidence of tumor recurrence was found. The best-fit equation for the learning curve based on surgical time was CUSUM=0.010X³-1.648X²-68.573X-61.091, and the best-fit equation for the learning curve based on robotic system setup time was CUSUM=0.0018X³-0.285X²+10.460X+57.541 (where X represents the number of surgeries). The R² values of 2 learning curve models were 0.953 and 0.957, respectively, and the fit model tests had <0.05. The inflection point of the learning curve based on surgical time was the 28th case, which is considered the minimum number of surgeries required to achieve proficiency in robotic-assisted retroperitoneal benign tumor resection. Based on this, the patients were divided into a learning group (cases 1 to 28) and a mastery group (cases 29 to 69). The surgical time for the learning group was significantly longer than that of the mastery group ((194.7±30.0) minutes (151.9±31.4) minutes, =4.126,<0.01). No statistically significant differences were found for other parameters (all >0.05). Robotic-assisted retroperitoneal benign tumor resection is feasible. The minimum number of surgeries required to achieve proficiency in overcoming the learning curve is about 28 cases.
探讨机器人辅助腹膜后良性肿瘤切除术的疗效并分析其学习曲线。这是一项回顾性病例系列研究。对2015年8月至2023年2月在腹膜后肿瘤外科接受机器人辅助腹膜后良性肿瘤切除术的患者数据进行回顾性分析。其中男性24例,女性45例,年龄为(46.3±10.6)岁(范围:19至76岁)。记录围手术期数据、术后病理结果及随访数据。采用累积和(CUSUM)法分析机器人系统设置时间和手术时间以绘制学习曲线。应用线性回归模型确定最佳拟合曲线,选择R²值最高的模型。根据手术时间学习曲线的顶点,将患者分为学习组和熟练组。比较两组的一般资料和围手术期情况。采用独立样本t检验、曼-惠特尼检验等进行比较。所有69例患者均成功完成手术,无术中并发症。肿瘤直径为(49.7±18.6)mm(范围:16至131mm)。机器人手术系统的设置时间为(35.3±9.8)分钟(范围:20至61分钟);手术时间为(169.2±36.5)分钟(范围:70至305分钟);术中出血量(四分位数间距)为10.0(15.0)ml(范围:2.0至200.0ml)。32例患者(46.4%)的肿瘤与主要血管粘连。所有患者均无并发症出院。随访至2024年2月,无患者因腹膜后良性肿瘤需要再次手术、再次入院或死亡。无严重长期并发症,未发现肿瘤复发的影像学证据。基于手术时间的学习曲线最佳拟合方程为CUSUM = 0.010X³ - 1.648X² - 68.573X - 61.091,基于机器人系统设置时间的学习曲线最佳拟合方程为CUSUM = 0.0018X³ - 0.285X² + 10.460X + 57.541(其中X代表手术例数)。两个学习曲线模型的R²值分别为0.953和0.957,拟合模型检验P<0.05。基于手术时间的学习曲线拐点为第28例,这被认为是熟练掌握机器人辅助腹膜后良性肿瘤切除术所需的最少手术例数。据此,将患者分为学习组(第1至28例)和熟练组(第29至69例)。学习组的手术时间明显长于熟练组((194.7±30.0)分钟对(151.9±31.4)分钟,t = 4.126,P<0.01)。其他参数未发现统计学显著差异(均P>0.05)。机器人辅助腹膜后良性肿瘤切除术是可行的。熟练掌握学习曲线所需的最少手术例数约为28例。