Wu Jianhao, Wang Yubo, Huang Yueting, Long Xuezhi, Tang Jiahui, Gu Di
Department of Urology, The First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou, 510230, Guangdong, China.
Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory of Urology, Guangzhou, Guangdong, China.
J Robot Surg. 2025 Jan 10;19(1):49. doi: 10.1007/s11701-024-02202-3.
This study applied cumulative sum (CUSUM) analysis to evaluate trends in operative time and blood loss, It aims to identify key milestones in mastering extraperitoneal single-site robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy (ss-RARP). A cohort of 100 patients who underwent ss-RARP, performed by a single surgeon at the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University between March 2021 and June 2023, was retrospectively analyzed. To evaluate the learning curve, the CUSUM (Cumulative Sum Control Chart) technique was applied, revealing the progression and variability over time. A cubic polynomial model was utilised to fit the non-linear data trends accurately. Key perioperative outcomes, such as operative duration and estimated blood loss, were assessed and compared between distinct learning stages to identify improvements and transitions during the surgeon's proficiency development. A total of 100 patients were included, with a mean age of 71.44 ± 5.46 years. The median operative time was 119.53 min (94, 144), and the best-fit equation for the CUSUM learning curve of operative time was y = 387.0373 - 3.4334x - 0.2982x + 0.003x (R = 0.898), reaching its peak at the 11th case. The median blood loss was 49.9 ml (20, 50), and the best-fit equation for the CUSUM learning curve of blood loss was y = 444.9362 + 23.6787x - 0.7719x + 0.0049x (R = 0.957), reaching its peak at the 27th case. The learning curve was divided into a learning phase (1-27 cases) and a proficient phase (28 cases onward). Intraoperative blood loss significantly decreased from 75.93 ± 79.19 mL to 40.27 ± 35.27 mL in the proficient phase (P < 0.05), while operative time remained similar between phases (P > 0.05).There were no statistically significant differences in pelvic drainage tube placement time, drainage volume, positive surgical margin rate, hospital stay duration, or postoperative pain scores (P > 0.05). The findings suggest that proficiency in ss-RARP is typically achieved after approximately 27 cases, indicating a manageable and safe learning curve. These insights can inform the design of surgical training programmes, optimising early learning and improving clinical outcomes for novice surgeons.
本研究应用累积和(CUSUM)分析来评估手术时间和失血量的趋势,旨在确定掌握腹膜外单孔机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术(ss-RARP)的关键里程碑。回顾性分析了2021年3月至2023年6月在广州医科大学附属第一医院由同一外科医生进行ss-RARP手术的100例患者队列。为评估学习曲线,应用了CUSUM(累积和控制图)技术,以揭示随时间的进展和变异性。采用三次多项式模型准确拟合非线性数据趋势。评估并比较了不同学习阶段的关键围手术期结局,如手术持续时间和估计失血量,以确定外科医生熟练程度发展过程中的改善和转变。共纳入100例患者,平均年龄为71.44±5.46岁。中位手术时间为119.53分钟(94,144),手术时间的CUSUM学习曲线的最佳拟合方程为y = 387.0373 - 3.4334x - 0.2982x + 0.003x(R = 0.898),在第11例时达到峰值。中位失血量为49.9毫升(20,50),失血量的CUSUM学习曲线的最佳拟合方程为y = 444.9362 + 23.6787x - 0.7719x + 0.0049x(R = 0.957),在第27例时达到峰值。学习曲线分为学习阶段(1 - 27例)和熟练阶段(28例及以后)。熟练阶段术中失血量从75.93±79.19毫升显著降至40.27±35.27毫升(P < 0.05),而各阶段手术时间相似(P > 0.05)。盆腔引流管放置时间、引流量、手术切缘阳性率、住院时间或术后疼痛评分无统计学显著差异(P > 0.05)。研究结果表明,ss-RARP的熟练程度通常在约27例手术后达到,表明学习曲线可控且安全。这些见解可为手术培训计划的设计提供参考,优化早期学习并改善新手外科医生的临床结局。