Baratte Clément, Sebbag Hugues, Arnalsteen Laurent, Auguste Thomas, Blanchet Marie-Cécile, Benchetrit Salomon, Abou-Mrad Adel, Reche Fabian, Genser Laurent, Caiazzo Robert, Lazzati Andrea, Catheline Jean-Marc, Pourcher Guillaume, Leyre Pierre, Kamoun-Zana Sandrine, Stenard Fabien, Coste Thibaut, Sterkers Adrien, Blanchard Claire, Poghosyan Tigran, Pattou François, Perretta Silvana, Robert Maud
Department of General, Digestive, Bariatric and Oesogastric SurgeryUniversity of Paris, centre de recherche sur l'inflammation UMR 1149, hôpital Bichat - Claude-Bernard, Assistance publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Inserm, 46, rue Henri-Huchard, 75018 Paris, France.
Hôpital privé de Provence, 200, allée Nicolas-de-Staël, 13080 Aix-en-Provence, France.
J Visc Surg. 2025 Feb;162(1):71-78. doi: 10.1016/j.jviscsurg.2024.12.003. Epub 2025 Jan 9.
IS ESG EFFECTIVE IN THE TREATMENT OF OBESITY AND ASSOCIATEDCOMORBIDITIES?: Endoscopic Sleeve Gastroplasty (ESG) is more effective than lifestyle modifications alone for weight loss and improving obesity-related comorbidities. While it has less effect on weight loss compared to Laparoscopic Sleeve Gastrectomy (LSG) in the short to medium term, it offers similar comorbidities resolution to LSG. IS ESG A SAFE PROCEDURE, AND WHAT ARE ITS RISKS?: The safety profile of ESG is consistently supported in the literature. Surgical complications after ESG, ranging from 1.5 to 2.3%, such as bleeding, perforation, fistula, or upper bowel obstruction, are rare and typically managed endoscopically. The incidence of new-onset gastro-esophageal reflux disease (GERD) is deemed negligible and occurs less frequently after ESG compared to SG. WHAT ARE THE INDICATIONS AND MANAGEMENT METHODS?: Multidisciplinary care for patients undergoing ESG should be provided in an accredited center authorized to perform bariatric and metabolic surgery, with validation through a multidisciplinary consultation meeting (RCP). Perioperative management should be personalized and ideally modeled after the protocols already in place for bariatric and metabolic surgery to ensure satisfactory and lasting weight and metabolic outcomes. Adherence to follow-up visits is a significant predictor of successful weight loss outcomes after ESG. Additionally, all endoscopic surgical procedures should be documented in a registry affiliated with a recognized scientific society, as is standard for other bariatric surgical procedures. WHICH HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS CAN PERFORM ESG?: ESG must be performed by a practitioner trained in endoscopy and obesity management, capable of ensuring thorough preoperative care and comprehensive postoperative follow-up, supported by an experienced multidisciplinary team. In France, Notice No. 2021.0040/AC/SEAP of June 10, 2021, issued by the Haute Autorité de santé (HAS) college, specifies that "the technology of ESG via the trans-oral approach, involving wide plication of the greater gastric curvature […] with an endoscopic suture placement device, enables a gastroenterologist or a visceral and digestive surgeon to perform gastric plication through digestive endoscopy by placing sutures in the stomach". Ideally, this should take place in an accredited center authorized to perform bariatric and metabolic surgery, such as those approved by the Agence régionale de santé (ARS), in accordance with Article R6123-212 of December 2022 of the French Public Health Code. WHAT ARE THE RECOMMENDATIONS AND VIEWS OF OTHER INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFICSOCIETIES?: ESG is an integral part of the therapeutic arsenal available to bariatric and metabolic surgeons, offering an effective and valuable treatment option for obesity in specific patient populations. The International Federation for the Surgery of Obesity (IFSO) Bariatric Endoscopy Committee, following a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis, endorsed ESG as an effective and valuable treatment for obesity. ESG is particularly beneficial for patients with class I and II obesity, as well as for those with class III obesity who are not suitable candidates for metabolic bariatric surgery. Additionally, it can be proposed as an addition to lifestyle interventions in adolescent patients with class II obesity. The SOFFCOMM endorses endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty (ESG) as an effective and valuable treatment for obesity and highlights the importance of appropriate patient selection, coupled with rigorous evaluation of long-term outcomes, to refine its indications further.
内镜下袖状胃成形术(ESG)在治疗肥胖症及相关合并症方面是否有效?:内镜下袖状胃成形术(ESG)在减肥和改善肥胖相关合并症方面比单纯的生活方式改变更有效。虽然在短期至中期内,与腹腔镜袖状胃切除术(LSG)相比,它对体重减轻的效果较小,但它在解决合并症方面与LSG相似。
ESG是一种安全的手术吗?其风险有哪些?:ESG的安全性在文献中得到了一致支持。ESG后的手术并发症发生率在1.5%至2.3%之间,如出血、穿孔、瘘管或上消化道梗阻等,较为罕见,通常通过内镜进行处理。新发性胃食管反流病(GERD)的发生率被认为可以忽略不计,与胃切除术(SG)相比,ESG后发生的频率更低。
ESG的适应症和管理方法有哪些?:对于接受ESG的患者,应在经认可的、有权进行减肥和代谢手术的中心提供多学科护理,并通过多学科咨询会议(RCP)进行验证。围手术期管理应个性化,理想情况下应参照已有的减肥和代谢手术方案进行制定,以确保获得满意且持久的体重和代谢结果。坚持随访是ESG术后减肥成功的重要预测指标。此外,所有内镜手术都应记录在与公认科学协会相关的登记册中,这是其他减肥手术的标准做法。
哪些医疗专业人员可以进行ESG?:ESG必须由接受过内镜检查和肥胖管理培训的从业者进行,能够确保全面的术前护理和全面的术后随访,并得到经验丰富的多学科团队的支持。在法国,2021年6月10日法国高等卫生管理局(HAS)学院发布的第2021.0040/AC/SEAP号通知规定,“经口途径的ESG技术,涉及胃大弯的广泛折叠[…] 使用内镜缝合放置装置,使胃肠病学家或内脏和消化外科医生能够通过在胃内放置缝线,通过消化内镜进行胃折叠术”。理想情况下,这应该在经认可的、有权进行减肥和代谢手术的中心进行,例如符合法国公共卫生法典2022年12月R6123 - 212条规定的地区卫生机构(ARS)批准的中心。
其他国际科学协会的建议和观点是什么?:ESG是减肥和代谢外科医生可用治疗手段的一个组成部分,为特定患者群体的肥胖症提供了一种有效且有价值的治疗选择。国际肥胖手术联合会(IFSO)减肥内镜委员会在进行全面系统回顾和荟萃分析后,认可ESG是一种有效且有价值的肥胖症治疗方法。ESG对I级和II级肥胖患者特别有益,对于不适合进行代谢性减肥手术的III级肥胖患者也适用。此外,对于II级肥胖的青少年患者,它可以作为生活方式干预的补充措施提出。SOFFCOMM认可内镜下袖状胃成形术(ESG)是一种有效且有价值的肥胖症治疗方法,并强调了适当选择患者的重要性,以及对长期结果进行严格评估以进一步完善其适应症的重要性。