Will Manuel, Rathmann Hannes
Department of Early Prehistory and Quaternary Ecology, University of Tübingen, 72070, Tübingen, Germany.
Palaeo-Research Institute, University of Johannesburg, P.O. Box 524, Auckland Park, ZA-2006, South Africa.
Sci Rep. 2025 Jan 10;15(1):1571. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-85399-z.
Lithic artefacts provide the principal means to study cultural change in the deep human past. Tools and cores have been the focus of much prior research based on their perceived information content and cultural relevance. Unretouched flakes rarely attract comparable attention in archaeological studies, despite being the most abundant assemblage elements and featuring prominently in ethnographic and experimental work. Here, we examine the potential of flake morphology for tracing cultural change utilising 4,512 flakes, each characterised by 16 standard mixed-scale attributes, from a well-documented cultural sequence at the Middle Stone Age site of Sibhudu, South Africa. We quantified multivariate similarities among flakes using FLEXDIST, a highly versatile method capable of handling mixed, correlated, incomplete, and high-dimensional data. Our findings reveal a significant gradual change in flake morphology that aligns with the documented cultural succession at Sibhudu. Furthermore, our analysis provides new insights into the patterning of variability throughout the studied sequence. The demonstrated potential of flakes to track cultural change opens up additional avenues for comparative research due to their ubiquity, the availability of commonly recorded attributes, and especially in the absence of cores or tools. FLEXDIST, with its versatile applicability to complex lithic datasets, holds particular promise in this regard.
石器文物是研究人类远古文化变迁的主要手段。基于工具和石核所蕴含的信息内容及文化关联性,它们一直是此前诸多研究的重点。未经修整的石片尽管是考古组合中最为丰富的元素,且在民族志和实验研究中占据显著地位,但在考古研究中却很少受到同等程度的关注。在此,我们利用来自南非西布杜中石器时代遗址一个记录完备的文化序列中的4512片石片,每片石片都由16个标准的混合尺度属性来表征,研究石片形态在追溯文化变迁方面的潜力。我们使用FLEXDIST量化了石片之间的多变量相似性,FLEXDIST是一种高度通用的方法,能够处理混合、相关、不完整和高维数据。我们的研究结果揭示了石片形态的显著渐变,这与西布杜记录的文化演替相一致。此外,我们的分析为整个研究序列中变异性的模式提供了新的见解。由于石片的普遍存在、常见记录属性的可得性,尤其是在没有石核或工具的情况下,石片在追踪文化变迁方面所展现出的潜力为比较研究开辟了新的途径。FLEXDIST因其对复杂石器数据集的广泛适用性,在这方面具有特别的前景。