感染艾滋病毒的女性面临来自感染、家庭暴力和其他边缘化身份的交叉污名:印度西孟加拉邦的一项定性研究。
Women living with HIV face intersectional stigma from infection, domestic violence, and other marginalized identities: a qualitative study in West Bengal, India.
作者信息
Mukerji Reshmi, Osrin David, Mannell Jenevieve
机构信息
Institute for Global Health, University College London, 30 Guilford Street, London, WC1N 1EH, UK.
出版信息
BMC Glob Public Health. 2025 Jan 10;3(1):4. doi: 10.1186/s44263-024-00122-w.
BACKGROUND
Women living with HIV bear a disproportionate burden of stigma, especially in countries where gender discrimination is more common. A result is widespread domestic violence against women. This violence is itself stigmatized, but the intersectional stigma of HIV and domestic violence has not been well studied. Our work aimed to fill this research gap by exploring how domestic violence and HIV stigma intersect with other marginalized identities in women's lives.
METHODS
Semi-structured interviews were conducted in Kolkata, India with 31 women living with HIV and 16 key informants to gain an understanding of intersecting stigmas. Interviewees discussed women's experiences and perceptions of stigma and discrimination around HIV, domestic violence, and other marginalized identities. The coding of data was informed by an intersectional stigma framework. Thematic Network Analysis was used to group themes originating in the data into higher-order themes connecting to a global theme.
RESULTS
The findings presented are a qualitative self-report of violence. The three main themes developed were (1) the intersectional stigma of HIV and domestic violence amplified stigma as a whole, (2) the intersection of multiple stigmas worsens domestic violence, and (3) the stigma of HIV hides domestic violence. Specifically, HIV stigma triggered domestic violence and perpetrators reinforced HIV stigma through verbal abuse. Women with other marginalized identities, such as having daughters or being a widow, experienced substantial violence. Domestic violence stigma was worsened by HIV stigma as women hid the violence for fear of revealing their status. As a result, help-seeking from formal and informal sources decreased, which increased women's isolation.
CONCLUSIONS
The findings shape new understandings of how intersectional stigma of HIV, domestic violence, and marginalized social identities interact to amplify stigma and related violence. Women living with HIV who have multiple marginalized identities should be prioritized for violence reduction interventions.
背景
感染艾滋病毒的女性承受着不成比例的耻辱负担,尤其是在性别歧视更为普遍的国家。结果是针对女性的家庭暴力普遍存在。这种暴力本身也受到污名化,但艾滋病毒与家庭暴力的交叉污名尚未得到充分研究。我们的工作旨在通过探索家庭暴力和艾滋病毒污名如何与女性生活中的其他边缘化身份相交织,来填补这一研究空白。
方法
在印度加尔各答对31名感染艾滋病毒的女性和16名关键信息提供者进行了半结构化访谈,以了解交叉污名。受访者讨论了女性在艾滋病毒、家庭暴力和其他边缘化身份方面的耻辱和歧视经历及看法。数据编码采用交叉污名框架。主题网络分析用于将数据中产生的主题分组为与一个全球主题相关的高阶主题。
结果
呈现的研究结果是对暴力的定性自我报告。形成的三个主要主题是:(1)艾滋病毒与家庭暴力的交叉污名加剧了整体污名;(2)多种污名的交织使家庭暴力恶化;(3)艾滋病毒污名掩盖了家庭暴力。具体而言,艾滋病毒污名引发了家庭暴力,施暴者通过言语虐待强化了艾滋病毒污名。具有其他边缘化身份的女性,如有女儿或丧偶的女性,遭受了大量暴力。由于女性因害怕暴露自己的身份而隐瞒暴力行为,艾滋病毒污名加剧了家庭暴力污名。结果,向正规和非正规渠道寻求帮助的行为减少,这增加了女性的孤立感。
结论
这些研究结果形成了对艾滋病毒、家庭暴力和边缘化社会身份的交叉污名如何相互作用以加剧污名和相关暴力的新理解。对于具有多种边缘化身份的感染艾滋病毒的女性,应优先实施减少暴力的干预措施。