Kelley Brenden, Ali Nawab, Dong Younsuk
Extension, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA.
Biosystems and Agricultural Engineering, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA.
MethodsX. 2024 Dec 14;14:103100. doi: 10.1016/j.mex.2024.103100. eCollection 2025 Jun.
Accurate soil moisture measurement is critical for precision irrigation management when using sensor data to calculate application timing and volume. Especially under conditions with soil varying temperature, sensors performance is always subject to some degree of error. This research investigated the method to assess soil moisture sensors performance across temperature gradient (4 °C to 14 °C) in sandy soil. Soil moisture was maintained stable, temperature was increased gradually and ΔVWC was measured for each increment across temperature. Results showed a linear decreasing trend between temperature rise and ΔVWC by 0.02 and 0.015 cm/cm for Teros-12 and 10-HS sensors while SoilWatch-10 exhibited a promising increasing trend. The observed (Oθ) and temperature-corrected (TCθ) VWC were compared through regression model and sensors performance was assessed through statistical metrics including Root Mean Square (RMSE), Index of Agreement (IA) and Mean Biased Error (MBE).•The RMSE values of 0.015, 0.011 and 0.031 cm/cm respectively for Teros-12, HS-10 and SoilWatch-10. This indicates that 10-HS exhibited the highest accuracy, followed by Teros-12, and lastly SoilWatch-10 sensor.•Strong agreement (IA = 0.99) between Oθ and TCθ showed the reliability of all sensors.•Teros-12 and 10-HS sensor showed slight under estimation (MBE = -0.014 and -0.011), while SoilWatch-10 indicated overestimation (MBE = 0.028).Thus, temperature correction is crucial for improving accuracy and minimizing over and/or underestimation ensuring precise detection of VWC by temperature-induced sensors.
在利用传感器数据计算灌溉时间和用量以进行精准灌溉管理时,准确测量土壤湿度至关重要。特别是在土壤温度变化的条件下,传感器的性能总会存在一定程度的误差。本研究探讨了在砂质土壤中评估土壤湿度传感器在温度梯度(4℃至14℃)下性能的方法。保持土壤湿度稳定,逐渐升高温度,并测量每个温度增量下的体积含水量变化(ΔVWC)。结果表明,对于Teros - 12和10 - HS传感器,温度升高与ΔVWC之间呈线性下降趋势,分别为0.02和0.015厘米/厘米,而SoilWatch - 10则呈现出有前景的上升趋势。通过回归模型比较了观测体积含水量(Oθ)和温度校正后的体积含水量(TCθ),并通过包括均方根误差(RMSE)、一致性指数(IA)和平均偏差误差(MBE)在内的统计指标评估传感器性能。•Teros - 12、HS - 10和SoilWatch - 10的RMSE值分别为0.015、0.011和0.031厘米/厘米。这表明10 - HS的精度最高,其次是Teros - 12,最后是SoilWatch - 10传感器。•Oθ和TCθ之间的强一致性(IA = 0.99)表明所有传感器的可靠性。•Teros - 12和10 - HS传感器显示出轻微低估(MBE = -0.014和-0.011),而SoilWatch - 10则表明高估(MBE = 0.028)。因此,温度校正对于提高精度以及最大限度减少高估和/或低估至关重要,可确保温度感应传感器精确检测体积含水量。