Yuan Yue, Wang Congcong, Wen Song, Li Yanyan, Xu Chenglin, Yu Fang, Li Xiucai, He Yanju, Chen Lijiao, Ren Yishu, Zhou Ligang
Department of Endocrinology, Shanghai Pudong Hospital, Fudan University, Shanghai, 201399, People's Republic of China.
Shanghai Key Laboratory of Vascular Lesions Regulation and Remodeling, Shanghai Pudong Hospital, Fudan University, Shanghai, 201399, People's Republic of China.
Diabetes Metab Syndr Obes. 2025 Jan 6;18:37-50. doi: 10.2147/DMSO.S489435. eCollection 2025.
Direct Observation of Procedural Skills (DOPS) is a clinical assessment tool that enables trainers to observe medical students' procedural abilities in real-time clinical settings. It assesses students' knowledge application, decision-making, and skill proficiency during clinical tasks.
This study modifies the DOPS to evaluate the operation of insulin pumps (PUMP) and continuous glucose monitoring systems (CGMS) in diabetes management. Key elements of the modified DOPS include 1) Knowledge Assessment: Evaluating understanding of PUMP and CGMS, including interpreting CGMS data for insulin adjustments; 2) Operational Skills: Assessing correct PUMP needle insertion, programming, and adjustments; 3) Patient Safety: Ensuring safe and aseptic procedures; 4) Feedback: Providing constructive feedback to help students improve their skills.
Training through DOPS led to significant improvements in all domains, overall performance scores, and reduced execution time for each domain. Correlations between domains showed that PUMP indication scores were linked to all other domains and execution times, including re-evaluation. Communication skills and seeking assistance were crucial factors influencing other domains. Multilinear regression analysis revealed that while DOPS-CGMS (R square 1.0) fully explained performance scores, DOPS-PUMP (R square 0.984) indicated that additional personal qualities significantly impacted students' PUMP operation performance.
This customized DOPS form offers insights into students' abilities in managing diabetes with PUMP and CGMS, while emphasizing the need for training on both technical skills and interpersonal skills in future educational models.
操作技能直接观察法(DOPS)是一种临床评估工具,可使培训人员在实际临床环境中实时观察医学生的操作能力。它评估学生在临床任务中的知识应用、决策能力和技能熟练程度。
本研究对DOPS进行了修改,以评估胰岛素泵(PUMP)和持续葡萄糖监测系统(CGMS)在糖尿病管理中的操作。修改后的DOPS的关键要素包括:1)知识评估:评估对PUMP和CGMS的理解,包括解读CGMS数据以调整胰岛素;2)操作技能:评估PUMP针头插入、编程和调整的正确性;3)患者安全:确保操作安全且无菌;4)反馈:提供建设性反馈以帮助学生提高技能。
通过DOPS进行培训使所有领域、总体表现得分均有显著提高,且每个领域的执行时间都有所减少。各领域之间的相关性表明,PUMP指标得分与所有其他领域及执行时间相关,包括重新评估。沟通技巧和寻求帮助是影响其他领域的关键因素。多元线性回归分析显示,虽然DOPS-CGMS(决定系数1.0)能完全解释表现得分,但DOPS-PUMP(决定系数0.984)表明,其他个人特质对学生的PUMP操作表现有显著影响。
这种定制的DOPS形式有助于深入了解学生使用PUMP和CGMS管理糖尿病的能力,同时强调在未来教育模式中对技术技能和人际技能培训的必要性。