Jones James Harvey, Fleming Neal
James Harvey Jones is an Assistant Clinical Professor in the Department of Anesthesiology at University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill, NC. Neal Fleming is a Professor of Clinical Anesthesiology in the Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine at University of California Davis Medical Center in Sacramento, CA.
J Educ Perioper Med. 2025 Jan 9;26(4):E731. doi: 10.46374/VolXXVI_Issue4_HarveyJones. eCollection 2024 Oct-Dec.
Expanding the physician workforce in underserved areas is imperative for addressing healthcare disparities. The creation of new residency training programs has assisted in these efforts. However, anesthesiology training programs are infrequently studied in this regard. Our objective was to compare the geographical distribution of newly accredited anesthesiology training programs with new surgery, obstetrics, and family practice programs with respect to health professional shortage areas (HPSAs) and medically underserved populations.
The locations of residency training programs accredited between 2014 and 2024 were identified by querying the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education and Fellowship and Residency Electronic Interactive Database Access System. Whether the postal address of the training program corresponded to a medically underserved area or population was then recorded. HPSA and maternal care target area (MCTA) scores were also collected as an indicator of poor access to primary care or maternal care for the postal addresses of each program. Bivariate US maps qualitatively compared the geographical distributions of newly accredited training programs, analysis of variance and tests were used to compare HPSA and MCTA scores, and χ tests were used to compare the percentage of programs in medically underserved areas.
Forty-eight anesthesiology programs became accredited between 2014 and 2024, as well as 127 surgical, 360 family medicine, and 68 obstetrical programs (total = 603). States with higher HPSA scores tended to have a relatively lower numbers of newly accredited anesthesiology and surgery programs. The mean HPSA and MCTA scores for anesthesiology programs were comparable to those for family medicine and obstetrical programs, respectively ( > .5). There was no statistically significant difference noted among the distribution of anesthesia, surgery, family medicine, or obstetrical training programs in medically underserved areas ( > .5).
The geographical distributions of new anesthesiology and surgery training programs are qualitatively similar. Like family medicine and obstetrical training programs, newly accredited anesthesiology training programs are in HPSAs with comparable need priorities as evidenced by statistically similar HPSA and MCTA scores. However, with only roughly one-third of all newly accredited family medicine, obstetrical, surgery, and anesthesiology training programs in medically underserved areas, substantial work is still needed.
States with higher HPSA scores tend to have a relatively lower number of newly accredited anesthesiology and surgery programs. The locations of newly accredited anesthesiology training programs are similar to those of newly accredited family medicine and obstetrical training programs as evidenced by similar HPSA and MCTA scores, respectively.
扩大医疗服务不足地区的医生队伍对于解决医疗保健差距至关重要。创建新的住院医师培训项目有助于这些努力。然而,麻醉学培训项目在这方面很少被研究。我们的目标是比较新认证的麻醉学培训项目与新的外科、产科和家庭医学项目在卫生专业人员短缺地区(HPSA)和医疗服务不足人群方面的地理分布。
通过查询毕业后医学教育认证委员会以及奖学金和住院医师电子交互式数据库访问系统,确定2014年至2024年期间认证的住院医师培训项目的地点。然后记录培训项目的邮政地址是否对应医疗服务不足地区或人群。还收集了HPSA和孕产妇护理目标地区(MCTA)分数,作为每个项目邮政地址获得初级保健或孕产妇护理机会差的指标。双变量美国地图定性比较了新认证培训项目的地理分布,使用方差分析和检验来比较HPSA和MCTA分数,使用χ检验来比较医疗服务不足地区项目的百分比。
2014年至2024年期间,有48个麻醉学项目获得认证,还有127个外科项目、360个家庭医学项目和68个产科项目(总计603个)。HPSA分数较高的州新认证的麻醉学和外科项目数量往往相对较少。麻醉学项目的平均HPSA和MCTA分数分别与家庭医学和产科项目的分数相当(>.5)。在医疗服务不足地区,麻醉、外科、家庭医学或产科培训项目的分布没有统计学上的显著差异(>.5)。
新的麻醉学和外科培训项目的地理分布在质量上相似。与家庭医学和产科培训项目一样,新认证的麻醉学培训项目位于需求优先级相当的HPSA地区,HPSA和MCTA分数在统计学上相似证明了这一点。然而,在所有新认证的家庭医学、产科、外科和麻醉学培训项目中,只有大约三分之一位于医疗服务不足地区,仍有大量工作要做。
HPSA分数较高的州新认证的麻醉学和外科项目数量往往相对较少。新认证的麻醉学培训项目的地点与新认证的家庭医学和产科培训项目的地点相似,分别由相似的HPSA和MCTA分数证明。