Manes Taylor J, Kelly Brendan E, Main Chris
Orthopedic Surgery, OhioHealth Doctors Hospital, Columbus, USA.
College of Osteopathic Medicine, Des Moines University, Des Moines, USA.
Cureus. 2024 Dec 15;16(12):e75741. doi: 10.7759/cureus.75741. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Tranexamic acid (TXA) is an antifibrinolytic drug commonly used in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Intravenous (IV) and topical TXA therapy have been extensively studied and shown to reduce blood loss, length of hospital stay, and blood transfusion rates following TKA. Despite the extensive literature regarding IV and topical TXA in orthopedics, there is a current dearth of studies analyzing oral usage. The primary purpose of this randomized controlled study is to compare post-surgical blood loss with the use of IV and oral TXA following a TKA.
In this multicenter, prospective, controlled, randomized study, patients were randomized to receive 1.95 grams of oral TXA two hours preoperatively or 15 mg/kg (1 gram max) of IV TXA mixed in 100 mL of normal saline preoperatively. Intraoperatively, each patient received a combination of 500 mg TXA mixed with 25 mL of normal saline injected into the suction drain and clamped for 30 minutes postoperatively. The primary outcome was absolute (g/dL) change in hemoglobin levels at 24 hours postoperatively. Secondary outcomes included a percent change in hematocrit levels and total drain output at 24 hours postoperatively. Power analysis determined that 40 patients were required in each group.
About 24 patients received IV TXA and 14 patients received oral TXA. The mean decrease in hemoglobin 24 hours postoperatively was not greater (p=0.12) with the use of oral TXA compared to IV TXA (1.70 g/dL vs. 2.50 g/dL, respectively). The mean decrease in hematocrit 24 hours postoperatively in the treatment (oral TXA) group was not greater (p=0.18) than the control (IV TXA) group (5.3% vs. 7.0%, respectively). Both changes in hemoglobin and hematocrit resulted in a normal distribution of data and satisfactory one-sided T-test values (p=0.98 and p=0.92, respectively). The mean drain output measured 24 hours postoperatively in the treatment group was significantly (p=0.04) less than the control group (47.5 mL vs. 170 mL, respectively). All tests performed were one-sided T-tests.
Compared to IV TXA, we found oral administration to have no significant difference in hemoglobin (p=0.12) or hematocrit (p=0.18) loss. These findings may support the utilization of oral TXA as a valid alternative to the IV route. We found that patients who received oral TXA produced significantly lower drainage output when compared to IV (47.5 mL and 170 mL, respectively; p=0.04). Persistent wound drainage following TKA has been correlated with increased rates of periprosthetic joint infections, residual pain, and reoperation. Further work is needed to assess the effect of postoperative drainage quantity on the recovery of TKA.
Based upon the data gathered, oral TXA does not result in greater loss of hemoglobin or hematocrit within 24 hours following surgery. However, total drain output was significantly less in the oral group after 24 hours following a TKA. With more subjects, we would expect to see the mean values between groups move closer to each other and fit well with the current literature. This suggests that oral TXA is non-inferior to IV TXA when comparing these variables following TKA. Our current study has limitations, including a small sample size and no blinding. Therefore, this study provided a limited quality of evidence. Confirmation with a blinded, randomized controlled trial and meta-analysis is required to report a higher quality of evidence.
氨甲环酸(TXA)是一种常用于全膝关节置换术(TKA)的抗纤维蛋白溶解药物。静脉注射(IV)和局部应用TXA疗法已得到广泛研究,并显示可减少TKA术后的失血量、住院时间和输血率。尽管骨科领域有大量关于静脉注射和局部应用TXA的文献,但目前分析口服用法的研究却很匮乏。这项随机对照研究的主要目的是比较TKA术后使用静脉注射和口服TXA后的手术失血量。
在这项多中心、前瞻性、对照、随机研究中,患者被随机分为两组,一组在术前两小时口服1.95克TXA,另一组在术前将15毫克/千克(最大1克)的静脉注射TXA混入100毫升生理盐水中。术中,每位患者接受500毫克TXA与25毫升生理盐水混合后注入吸引引流管,并在术后夹闭30分钟。主要结局是术后24小时血红蛋白水平的绝对(克/分升)变化。次要结局包括术后24小时血细胞比容水平的百分比变化和总引流量。功效分析确定每组需要40名患者。
约24名患者接受静脉注射TXA,14名患者接受口服TXA。与静脉注射TXA相比,口服TXA术后24小时血红蛋白的平均下降幅度并无显著差异(p = 0.12)(分别为1.70克/分升和2.50克/分升)。治疗(口服TXA)组术后24小时血细胞比容的平均下降幅度并不大于对照组(静脉注射TXA)(分别为5.3%和7.0%;p = 0.18)。血红蛋白和血细胞比容的变化均导致数据呈正态分布,且单侧T检验值令人满意(分别为p = 0.98和p = 0.92)。治疗组术后24小时测量的平均引流量显著低于对照组(分别为47.5毫升和170毫升;p = 0.04)。所有测试均为单侧T检验。
与静脉注射TXA相比,我们发现口服给药在血红蛋白(p = 0.12)或血细胞比容(p = 0.18)损失方面无显著差异。这些发现可能支持将口服TXA作为静脉注射途径的有效替代方法。我们发现,与静脉注射组相比,接受口服TXA的患者引流量显著更低(分别为47.5毫升和170毫升;p = 0.04)。TKA术后持续伤口引流与假体周围关节感染率增加、残留疼痛和再次手术相关。需要进一步研究来评估术后引流量对TKA恢复的影响。
根据收集的数据,口服TXA在术后24小时内不会导致血红蛋白或血细胞比容的更大损失。然而,TKA术后24小时后口服组的总引流量显著更少。纳入更多受试者后,我们预计两组之间的平均值会更接近,并与当前文献相符。这表明在TKA术后比较这些变量时,口服TXA不劣于静脉注射TXA。我们目前的研究存在局限性,包括样本量小且未采用盲法。因此,本研究提供的证据质量有限。需要通过一项采用盲法的随机对照试验和荟萃分析来确认,以报告更高质量的证据。