Araújo Ana Catarina de Melo, da Silva Thales Philipe Rodrigues, Velasquez-Melendez Gustavo, Nascimento Luciana Maiara Diogo, Ferraz Carla Conceição, Matozinhos Fernanda Penido, Fernandes Eder Gatti
Coordenadora-Geral de incorporação cientifica e Imunização, Ministério da Saúde Secretaria de Vigilância em Saúde e Ambiente, Departamento de Doenças Imunopreveníveis, Coordenação-Geral de Incorporação Cientifica e Imunizações, Doutora em Enfermagem pela Universidade Estadual de Pernambuco, Brasília, Brazil.
Doutor em Ciências da Saúde - Saúde da Criança e do Adolescente pela Faculdade de Medicina da UFMG. Residente Pós-doutoral pelo programa de Pós-graduação em Enfermagem da EE UFMG. Departamento de Enfermagem na Saúde da Mulher. Escola Paulista de Enfermagem - EPE, Universidade Federal de São Paulo - UNIFESP. Vice-líder do grupo de Pesquisa OPESV - Observatório de Pesquisa e Estudos em Vacinação, São Paulo, Brazil.
BMC Public Health. 2025 Jan 18;25(1):217. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-21326-1.
Immunization is a significant public health achievement for the whole world, although the population's adherence to vaccination efforts remains a concern. To address this, Brazil's Ministry of Health introduced the concept of operational microplanning (OM) for high-quality vaccination activities (HQVA) in 2023 to ensure excellence in routine service and campaigns. OM is defined by structured interventions using assertive techniques to enhance the likelihood of covering a broader population previously unprotected from vaccine-preventable diseases.
To assess the adherence of states and municipalities to OM for HQVA and examine the relationship between adherence levels and increased vaccination coverage in Brazil.
Adopting an epidemiological approach with an ecological design, this study analyzed data on the adherence of the 27 Brazilian federative units to HQVA, as reported through the REDCap electronic form in 2023, as per an agreement with the Ministry of Health. The criteria for assessing the states' adherence to the OM included: (1) Formation of a coordination committee for the OM for HQVA; (2) Inclusion of representatives from Primary Care in the committee; (3) Inclusion of representatives from COSEMS in the committee; (4) Regular coordination meetings between health surveillance and primary care for vaccination actions; and (5) Utilization of a management tool for decision-making and strategic planning (e.g., SWOT). Adherence levels were categorized as: 0 = High adherence (responding positively to 4 or 5 criteria); 1 = Medium adherence (3 positive responses); 2 = Low adherence (2 or fewer positive responses). For municipalities, the adherence criteria were similar, excluding the COSEMS representation and focusing on the involvement of primary care representatives.
The findings indicated that 45.75% of municipalities achieved full adherence, implementing all the evaluated actions. Despite declaring adherence to the OM, ~ 30.68% of municipalities executed two actions, 19.27% only one, and 4.30% none. Among the states, 37.04% showed full adherence by employing all evaluated actions, with 33.33% executing four actions. States with higher adherence levels to the OM also had greater vaccination coverage (VC), particularly in 2023. Municipalities with complete adherence to the OM met the VC objectives for polio (D3), 10-valent pneumococcal (D2), and triple viral (D1) vaccines in 2023. In states with full adherence to the OM, most municipalities achieved the VC targets for all evaluated vaccines in 2023, showing statistical significance for pentavalent (D3), polio (D3), and 10-valent pneumococcal (D2) vaccines.
The findings underscore the impact of OM on improving VC in Brazil, demonstrating that its effective implementation is correlated with meeting VC targets, especially in states and municipalities that enacted all recommended actions. Municipalities engaging in all OM actions met VC objectives for crucial vaccines, highlighting the OM's positive influence on VC. Full adherence to the OM by states correlated with a notable rise in VC averages across all analyzed vaccines. This analysis suggests that higher adherence to OM improves VC outcomes, emphasizing the role of OM in these metrics and shows that comprehensive implementation of OM improves vaccination efforts and significantly boosts VC, particularly in states fully adhering to guidelines.
免疫接种是一项对全世界意义重大的公共卫生成就,尽管民众对疫苗接种工作的依从性仍是一个令人担忧的问题。为解决这一问题,巴西卫生部于2023年引入了高质量疫苗接种活动的操作微观规划(OM)概念,以确保常规服务和疫苗接种活动的卓越性。OM通过运用果断的技术进行结构化干预来定义,以提高覆盖更多此前未受疫苗可预防疾病保护人群的可能性。
评估巴西各州和各市对高质量疫苗接种活动的操作微观规划的依从性,并研究依从水平与疫苗接种覆盖率提高之间的关系。
本研究采用生态设计的流行病学方法,根据与卫生部的协议,分析了2023年通过REDCap电子表格报告的巴西27个联邦单位对高质量疫苗接种活动的依从性数据。评估各州对操作微观规划依从性的标准包括:(1)成立高质量疫苗接种活动操作微观规划协调委员会;(2)委员会中纳入基层医疗代表;(3)委员会中纳入州卫生监测系统(COSEMS)代表;(4)卫生监督部门和基层医疗部门就疫苗接种行动定期召开协调会议;(5)使用管理工具进行决策和战略规划(如SWOT分析)。依从水平分为:0 = 高依从性(对4项或5项标准回答为是);1 = 中等依从性(3项肯定回答);2 = 低依从性(2项或更少肯定回答)。对于各市,依从标准类似,不包括州卫生监测系统代表,重点关注基层医疗代表的参与情况。
研究结果表明,45.75% 的市实现了完全依从,实施了所有评估行动。尽管宣称依从操作微观规划,但约30.68% 的市执行了两项行动,19.27% 的市仅执行了一项行动,4.30% 的市一项行动也未执行。在各州中,37.04% 的州通过采取所有评估行动表现出完全依从,33.33% 的州执行了四项行动。对操作微观规划依从性较高的州疫苗接种覆盖率(VC)也更高,尤其是在2023年。完全依从操作微观规划的市在2023年达到了脊髓灰质炎(D3)、10价肺炎球菌(D2)和三联病毒(D1)疫苗的接种覆盖率目标。在完全依从操作微观规划的州,大多数市在2023年实现了所有评估疫苗的接种覆盖率目标,五价(D3)、脊髓灰质炎(D3)和10价肺炎球菌(D2)疫苗具有统计学意义。
研究结果强调了操作微观规划对提高巴西疫苗接种覆盖率的影响,表明其有效实施与实现接种覆盖率目标相关,特别是在实施了所有推荐行动的州和市。参与所有操作微观规划行动的市达到了关键疫苗的接种覆盖率目标,突出了操作微观规划对接种覆盖率的积极影响。各州对操作微观规划的完全依从与所有分析疫苗的接种覆盖率平均值显著上升相关。该分析表明,更高的操作微观规划依从性可改善接种覆盖率结果,强调了操作微观规划在这些指标中的作用,并表明全面实施操作微观规划可改善疫苗接种工作并显著提高接种覆盖率,特别是在完全遵守指南的州。