Maximous Stephanie I, Acho Megan, Ahari Jalil, Hawkins Katrina, Jamieson Daniel B, Luks Andrew M, Poston Jason, Seam Nitin, Shah Nirav G, Sun Junfeng, Woods Christian J, Lee Burton W
Division of Pulmonary, Allergy, Critical Care, and Sleep Medicine, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
ATS Sch. 2025 Jun;6(2):191-201. doi: 10.34197/ats-scholar.2024-0036OC. Epub 2025 Jan 15.
Rapid accumulation of knowledge and skills by trainees in the intensive care unit assumes prior mastery of clinically relevant core physiology concepts. However, for many fellows, their foundational physiology knowledge was acquired years earlier during their preclinical medical curricula and variably reinforced during the remainder of their undergraduate and graduate medical training. We sought to assess the retention of clinically relevant pulmonary physiology knowledge among pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM) and critical care medicine (CCM) fellows. A composite examination was developed from an initial set of questions used in preclinical pulmonary physiology courses at four separate medical schools. These questions passed through multiple rounds of review by various educators to arrive at a set of 15 multiple-choice questions. The test was administered to incoming first-year PCCM and CCM fellows at seven institutions during their 2021 fellowship orientation. Forty-one first-year PCCM ( = 24) and CCM ( = 17) fellows completed the examination, and the proportion correct among the fellows was compared with that of medical students for each item. Although all questions were deemed to be clinically relevant, preclinical medical students significantly outperformed the incoming fellows. These findings suggest considerable decay of clinically relevant pulmonary physiologic knowledge during residency training and point to a need for longitudinal retrieval practice to reinforce these concepts during the course of medical school clerkship years and postgraduate clinical training as well as consideration of dedicated pulmonary physiology curricula for PCCM and CCM fellowship programs.
重症监护病房的学员要快速积累知识和技能,需先掌握临床相关的核心生理学概念。然而,对于许多住院医师而言,他们的基础生理学知识是多年前在临床前医学课程中获得的,在本科和研究生医学培训的剩余时间里得到的强化程度各不相同。我们试图评估肺与重症医学(PCCM)和重症医学(CCM)住院医师对临床相关肺生理学知识的掌握情况。从四所不同医学院临床前肺生理学课程最初使用的一组问题中编制了一份综合考试。这些问题经过了多位教育工作者的多轮审查,最终形成了一组15道多项选择题。在2021年住院医师入职培训期间,对七所机构新入学的一年级PCCM和CCM住院医师进行了测试。41名一年级PCCM(n = 24)和CCM(n = 17)住院医师完成了考试,并将住院医师的每题正确比例与医学生的进行了比较。尽管所有问题都被认为与临床相关,但临床前医学生的表现明显优于新入学的住院医师。这些发现表明,在住院医师培训期间,临床相关肺生理学知识出现了相当程度的衰退,这表明需要进行纵向复习练习,以便在医学院实习年限和研究生临床培训过程中强化这些概念,同时也需要考虑为PCCM和CCM住院医师培训项目设置专门的肺生理学课程。