Tawfik Fairouz, Ryland Howard, Yosef Mostafa, Morsy Mahmoud, Kaligis Fransiska, Noël Camille, Abdulhakim Mohamed, Mazereel Victor, Palavra Irena Rojnić, Prošev Andrej, Fiorillo Andrea, Sampogna Gaia, Durán Xenia Margarita, Jurado Jesús David Martínez, Ibrahim Islam
Department of Neurology and Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt.
Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust and Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, UK.
Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2025 Aug;71(5):954-967. doi: 10.1177/00207640241308197. Epub 2025 Jan 23.
The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated substantial modifications in the delivery of patient care on a global scale. Telemedicine-based care services were implemented worldwide to maximize access to healthcare systems.
This study aimed to investigate the use of and satisfaction with telepsychiatry services implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic by psychiatrists across low, middle, and high income countries, and to assess levels of burnout among psychiatrists providing telepsychiatry services in different settings and countries. We hypothesized that use of telepsychiatry will have increased during the pandemic and is associated with increased risk of burnout.
A cross-sectional survey was conducted from October 2020 to June 2021 on psychiatrists practicing in Egypt, United Kingdom, Croatia, Belgium, Indonesia, Italy, and El Salvador. Participants were asked to provide sociodemographic data and to complete a questionnaire developed ad-hoc by the authors on telepsychiatry use, the Modified Arizona Telemedicine Program Satisfaction (MATPS) survey and the Oldenburg Burnout Inventory questionnaire.
A total of 347 participants completed the survey. Sixty three percent indicated that they had not utilized teleservices for clinical consultation or academic purposes prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. A substantial shift was observed during the pandemic, with this percentage increasing to 98%. Over two-thirds of psychiatrists expressed satisfaction with the visual (76%) and audio (77%) aspects of teleconsultation. No significant correlation was found between burnout and satisfaction. While older age was negatively correlated with burnout levels, years of experience showed a positive correlation with levels of burnout.
While there was an increased acceptance and satisfaction with teleconsultation, a persistent preference for in-person consultations remained. The study did not find a correlation between satisfaction in telepsychiatry and levels of burnout. Moreover, increasing age was correlated with lower burn out rate, whereas a correlation between years of experience and heightened levels of burnout was evident.
新冠疫情使得全球范围内的患者护理服务交付方式发生了重大改变。基于远程医疗的护理服务在全球范围内得到实施,以最大限度地扩大医疗系统的可及性。
本研究旨在调查低收入、中等收入和高收入国家的精神科医生在新冠疫情期间对远程精神病学服务的使用情况和满意度,并评估在不同环境和国家提供远程精神病学服务的精神科医生的倦怠程度。我们假设在疫情期间远程精神病学的使用有所增加,并且与倦怠风险增加有关。
2020年10月至2021年6月对在埃及、英国、克罗地亚、比利时、印度尼西亚、意大利和萨尔瓦多执业的精神科医生进行了一项横断面调查。参与者被要求提供社会人口学数据,并完成作者专门设计的关于远程精神病学使用情况、改良亚利桑那远程医疗项目满意度(MATPS)调查和奥尔登堡倦怠量表问卷的调查问卷。
共有347名参与者完成了调查。63%的人表示在新冠疫情之前他们没有将远程服务用于临床咨询或学术目的。在疫情期间观察到了显著变化,这一比例增加到了98%。超过三分之二的精神科医生对远程会诊的视觉(76%)和音频(77%)方面表示满意。未发现倦怠与满意度之间存在显著相关性。虽然年龄较大与倦怠程度呈负相关,但工作年限与倦怠程度呈正相关。
虽然对远程会诊的接受度和满意度有所提高,但对面对面会诊的持续偏好仍然存在。该研究未发现远程精神病学满意度与倦怠程度之间存在相关性。此外,年龄增长与较低的倦怠率相关,而工作年限与较高的倦怠程度之间的相关性很明显。