Block P J, Popp R L
Am J Cardiol. 1985 Apr 1;55(8):937-40. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(85)90721-0.
Two-dimensional echocardiography (2-D echo) of the left main coronary artery (LMCA) was attempted in 50 patients undergoing arteriography to evaluate 2-D echo for recognition of significant stenosis of the LMCA. Although the echocardiographer was experienced and used rigorous technique, visualization of the LMCA adequate for making a judgment regarding lumen reduction was possible in only 37 patients (74%). Of the 10 studies with suspected positive findings for LMCA stenosis by 2-D echo, 4 yielded true-positive and 6 false-positive results. A study from 1 other patient with LMCA stenosis by angiography was erroneously interpreted as negative by 2-D echo. Analysis of arteriograms in the 6 patients with false positive 2-D echo readings failed to implicate significant proximal left anterior descending artery narrowing as the cause of the errors. Although 2-D echo was correct in indicating the presence or absence of LMCA stenosis in 30 of 37 patients, and the predictive value of a negative 2-D echo response was 96%, the noninvasive method appears to be inadequate as a screening test. Widespread use of the procedure is limited by the 26% failure rate for adequate studies in experienced hands, and the implications of the occasional false-negative finding. If LMCA stenosis is suspected by 2-D echo in a patient who needs arteriography, the special care given to this possibility by the arteriographer should not harm the patient.
对50例接受动脉造影的患者进行了左冠状动脉主干(LMCA)的二维超声心动图(2-D echo)检查,以评估2-D echo识别LMCA严重狭窄的能力。尽管超声心动图检查人员经验丰富且技术严格,但仅在37例患者(74%)中获得了足以判断管腔狭窄的LMCA图像。在二维超声心动图怀疑LMCA狭窄结果阳性的10例研究中,4例为真阳性,6例为假阳性。另1例经血管造影证实有LMCA狭窄的患者,其二维超声心动图检查结果被错误地判为阴性。对二维超声心动图假阳性读数的6例患者的动脉造影片分析显示,左前降支近端明显狭窄并非导致误诊的原因。尽管二维超声心动图在37例患者中的30例正确判断了LMCA狭窄的有无,且二维超声心动图阴性结果的预测价值为96%,但作为一种筛查方法,这种非侵入性检查似乎并不充分。该检查方法在经验丰富的检查人员手中仍有26%的失败率,且偶尔会出现假阴性结果,这限制了其广泛应用。如果二维超声心动图怀疑某患者存在LMCA狭窄而需要进行动脉造影,动脉造影检查人员对此可能性的特别关注不应给患者带来伤害。