Shabani Josephine, Salim Nahya, Bohne Christine, Day Louise Tina, Kumalija Claud, Makuwani Ahmad Mohamed, Bundala Felix, Ismail Habib, Lawn Joy E, Ohuma Eric O
Ifakara Health Institute, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences (MUHAS), Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
BMC Pediatr. 2025 Jan 23;23(Suppl 2):658. doi: 10.1186/s12887-025-05417-x.
The Every Newborn Action Plan (ENAP) indicators are essential in monitoring neonatal healthcare coverage and quality. The District Health Information System (DHIS2), an open-source platform in over 80 countries, supports health data collection and analysis, enabling progress tracking at national and subnational levels. This study evaluates the availability and quality of maternal and newborn health indicators, explicitly focusing on ENAP indicators within Tanzania's DHIS2.
Using the EN-MINI tool, we assessed data availability for 20 ENAP indicators by analysing their numerators and denominators in Tanzania's DHIS2 (2015-2022) across all healthcare levels. World Health Organization's (WHO) data quality framework was adapted to examine four dimensions: (a) availability of indicators, (b) completeness of indicator reporting, (c) internal consistency of related indicators, and (d) indicator plausibility by comparing DHIS2 data with population-based Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) data.
Of the 20 ENAP indicators, 14 were available in Tanzania's DHIS2, with definitions, numerators and denominators aligned with WHO standards. Between 2015 and 2022, the number of facilities reporting at least one delivery annually increased by 19% from 5,898 to 7,016. During this period, 75% to 97% of facilities consistently reported data on skilled attendance at birth and early breastfeeding initiation. In contrast, 4% to 54% of facilities reported on maternal and newborn outcomes, including complications such as stillbirths and maternal mortality. Internal consistency was high (> 94%). However, neonatal mortality rates reported in DHIS2 were lower than those reported in Tanzania DHS for similar periods, even after a 20% adjustment to account for home births.
Tanzania's DHIS2 captures many ENAP indicators; however, notable variability in data quality persists, with substantial data gaps related to maternal and newborn outcomes and complications. To address these challenges, it is crucial to strengthen routine data review, implement robust quality checks, enhance validation processes, provide targeted training, deliver constructive feedback, and conduct supportive supervision. Placing greater emphasis on using DHIS2 data to monitor progress will help identify gaps and drive improvements in data quality, ultimately supporting better maternal and newborn health outcomes.
《每一名新生儿行动计划》(ENAP)指标对于监测新生儿医疗保健覆盖范围和质量至关重要。地区卫生信息系统(DHIS2)是一个在80多个国家使用的开源平台,支持卫生数据的收集和分析,能够在国家和国家以下层面追踪进展情况。本研究评估了孕产妇和新生儿健康指标的可获取性和质量,特别关注坦桑尼亚DHIS2中的ENAP指标。
我们使用EN-MINI工具,通过分析坦桑尼亚DHIS2(2015 - 2022年)中所有医疗保健层面的分子和分母,评估了20项ENAP指标的数据可获取性。采用世界卫生组织(WHO)的数据质量框架来考察四个维度:(a)指标的可获取性,(b)指标报告的完整性,(c)相关指标的内部一致性,以及(d)通过将DHIS2数据与基于人群的人口与健康调查(DHS)数据进行比较来评估指标的合理性。
在20项ENAP指标中,坦桑尼亚的DHIS2中有14项指标可获取,其定义、分子和分母均符合WHO标准。2015年至2022年期间,每年至少报告一次分娩情况的医疗机构数量从5898家增加了19%,达到7016家。在此期间,75%至97%的医疗机构持续报告了有关熟练助产和早期开始母乳喂养的数据。相比之下,4%至54%的医疗机构报告了孕产妇和新生儿结局,包括死产和孕产妇死亡等并发症。内部一致性较高(>94%)。然而,即使在对在家分娩情况进行20%的调整后,DHIS2中报告的新生儿死亡率仍低于坦桑尼亚同期人口与健康调查中的报告数据。
坦桑尼亚的DHIS2涵盖了许多ENAP指标;然而,数据质量仍存在显著差异,在孕产妇和新生儿结局及并发症方面存在大量数据缺口。为应对这些挑战,加强常规数据审查、实施严格的质量检查、完善验证流程、提供针对性培训、给予建设性反馈以及进行支持性监督至关重要。更加重视利用DHIS2数据监测进展情况将有助于发现缺口并推动数据质量改进,最终支持实现更好的孕产妇和新生儿健康结局。