Nie Jia, Ge Calvin B, Rothman Nathaniel, Hu Wei, Vermeulen Roel, Lan Qing, Peters Susan
Institute for Risk Assessment Sciences, Utrecht University, Yalelaan 2, 3584 CM Utrecht, the Netherlands.
Netherlands Organization for Applied Scientific Research TNO, Princetonlaan 6, 3584 CB Utrecht, the Netherlands.
Ann Work Expo Health. 2025 Mar 15;69(3):251-260. doi: 10.1093/annweh/wxae103.
Trichloroethylene (TCE) is a carcinogen that has been causally linked to kidney cancer and possibly other cancer sites including the liver and lymphatic system. Its use in China has increased since the early 1990s due to the growing metal and electronic industries. We aimed to summarize the major sources of occupational exposure to TCE over time in China.
Occupational TCE exposure assessments were extracted from both the Chinese and English scientific literature, as well as from industrial hygiene surveys performed in Guangdong, Tianjin, and Hong Kong. Weighted mean concentrations were summarized by occupation and industry.
We extracted over 12,412 measurements from 55 industries and 35 occupations across China since 1976, of which at least 201 were from case reports. More than half of the measurements were derived from 4 industries, including "manufacture of footwear" (29%), "manufacture of electronic components and boards" (17%), "manufacture of games and toys" (14%), and "manufacture of fabricated metal products, except machinery and equipment" (13%). Several occupations, including "electronic-equipment assemblers," "metal-, rubber-, and plastic-products assemblers," "metal finishing-, plating-, and coating-machine operators," "precision-instrument makers and repairers," "printing-machine operators," and "ore and metal furnace operators" were identified as having high risks of TCE exposure, with either pooled weighted mean task-based or full-shift concentrations over 150 mg/m3 over the years. TCE exposure levels varied across different occupations and changed over time. In 1990 and earlier, 1991 to 2000, the exposure levels were at their highest with pooled weighted mean task-based concentrations of 202.8 and 242.9 mg/m3, respectively. Subsequently, the level decreased to 118.7 mg/m3 from 2001 to 2010 before increasing again to 216.0 mg/m3 from 2011 onwards. This overall trend was also observed for "electronic-equipment assemblers" and "metal finishing-, plating-, and coating-machine operators." However, for "precision-instrument makers and repairers," the exposure levels consistently declined over the years.
Over the past few decades, degreasing-related occupations, such as "electronic-equipment assemblers" and "metal finishing-, plating-, and coating-machine operators" have been consistently identified as being at high risk of significant TCE exposure and continued to warrant attention. Identifying high-risk industries and occupations can inform the development of targeted interventions and regulations to mitigate TCE exposure. Furthermore, enhancing the quality and coverage of exposure measurement data in occupational settings will advance epidemiological investigations in occupational health.
三氯乙烯(TCE)是一种致癌物,已被证实与肾癌有因果关系,还可能与包括肝脏和淋巴系统在内的其他癌症部位有关。自20世纪90年代初以来,由于金属和电子行业的不断发展,其在中国的使用量有所增加。我们旨在总结中国不同时期职业接触TCE的主要来源。
从中文和英文科学文献以及在广东、天津和香港进行的工业卫生调查中提取职业TCE接触评估数据。按职业和行业汇总加权平均浓度。
自1976年以来,我们从中国55个行业和35个职业中提取了超过12412次测量数据,其中至少201次来自病例报告。超过一半的测量数据来自4个行业,包括“制鞋业”(29%)、“电子元件及电路板制造业”(17%)、“游戏及玩具制造业”(14%)和“金属制品制造业(不包括机械和设备)”(13%)。几个职业,包括“电子设备装配工”、“金属、橡胶和塑料制品装配工”、“金属表面处理、电镀和涂层机器操作员”、“精密仪器制造和修理工”、“印刷机器操作员”以及“矿石和金属熔炉操作员”,被确定为具有高TCE接触风险,多年来基于任务的汇总加权平均浓度或全时班浓度超过150毫克/立方米。TCE接触水平因不同职业而异,并随时间变化。在1990年及以前、1991年至2000年,接触水平最高,基于任务的汇总加权平均浓度分别为202.8和242.9毫克/立方米。随后,2001年至2010年降至118.7毫克/立方米,2011年起再次升至216.0毫克/立方米。“电子设备装配工”和“金属表面处理、电镀和涂层机器操作员”也呈现出这种总体趋势。然而,“精密仪器制造和修理工”的接触水平多年来持续下降。
在过去几十年中,与脱脂相关的职业,如“电子设备装配工”和“金属表面处理、电镀和涂层机器操作员”,一直被确定为有高TCE显著接触风险,仍需持续关注。识别高风险行业和职业可为制定有针对性的干预措施和法规以减轻TCE接触提供依据。此外,提高职业环境中接触测量数据的质量和覆盖范围将推动职业健康方面的流行病学调查。