Gaillard Maxence, Pence Charles H, Botbol-Baum Mylène
Centre for Medical Ethics, Oslo (Norway) & Institut supérieur de philosophie, University of Oslo, UCLouvain, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium.
Institut supérieur de philosophie, UCLouvain, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium.
Biol Cell. 2025 Jan;117(1):e2400093. doi: 10.1111/boc.202400093.
The advancement of and prospects for stem cell research raise a number of specific ethical issues. While navigating the ethical landscape of stem cell research is often challenging for biology researchers and biotechnology innovators, it is also difficult for the public and other persons of concern (from ethicists to policy-makers) to grasp the technicalities of a burgeoning field that develops in many directions. Organoids are one of these new biotechnological constructs that are currently eliciting a rich debate in bioethics. In this guide, we argue that different types of organoids have different emerging properties with different ethical implications. Going from general properties to particular ones, we propose a typology of organoid technology and other associated biotechnology from a philosophical and ethical perspective. We point to relevant ethical issues and try to convey the sense of uncertainty peculiar to ongoing research and emerging technological objects.
干细胞研究的进展与前景引发了一些特定的伦理问题。虽然对于生物学研究人员和生物技术创新者而言,在干细胞研究的伦理领域中前行往往具有挑战性,但对于公众和其他相关人士(从伦理学家到政策制定者)来说,要理解一个朝着多个方向发展的新兴领域的技术细节也并非易事。类器官是这些新型生物技术构建物之一,目前正引发生物伦理学领域的热烈讨论。在本指南中,我们认为不同类型的类器官具有不同的新兴特性,有着不同的伦理含义。从一般特性到特殊特性,我们从哲学和伦理角度提出了类器官技术及其他相关生物技术的分类。我们指出相关的伦理问题,并试图传达正在进行的研究和新兴技术对象所特有的不确定性。