Lin Yih-Lon, Chiang Yu-Min, Tsai Tsuen-Chiuan, Su Sheng-Gui
Department of Computer Science and Information Engineering, National Yunlin University of Science and Technology, Yunlin, Taiwan.
Department of Automation Engineering, National Formosa University, No.64, Wunhua Rd., 632 Huwei Township, Yunlin, Taiwan.
BMC Med Inform Decis Mak. 2025 Jan 24;25(1):39. doi: 10.1186/s12911-025-02866-3.
In medical education, enhancing thinking skills is vital. The Virtual Diagnosis and Treatment Platform (VP) refines medical students' diagnostic abilities through interactive patient interviews (simulated patient interactions). By analyzing the questions asked during these interviews, the VP evaluates students' aptitude in medical history inquiries, offering insights into their thinking capabilities. This study aimed to extract insights from case summaries and patient interviews to improve evaluation and feedback in medical education.
This study employs a systematic approach to knowledge-point classification by utilizing both simple long short-term memory (LSTM)-based and Siamese-based networks, coupled with cross-validation techniques. The dataset under scrutiny originates from the "Clinical Diagnosis and Treatment Skills Competitions" spanning the first to third years in Taiwan. The methodology involves generating knowledge points from sequential questions posed during case summaries and patient interviews. These knowledge points are then subjected to classification using the designated neural network architectures.
The experimental findings reveal promising outcomes, particularly when the Siamese-based network is used for knowledge-point classification. Through repeated (stratified) 10-fold cross validation, the accuracies achieved consistently exceeded 93%, with a standard deviation less than 0.007. These results underscore the efficacy of the proposed methodologies in enhancing virtual clinical diagnosis systems.
This study underscores the viability of leveraging advanced neural network architectures, particularly the Siamese-based network, for knowledge-point classification within virtual clinical diagnosis systems. By effectively discerning and classifying knowledge points derived from case summaries and patient interviews, these systems offer invaluable insights into students' thinking capabilities in medical education. The robust accuracies attained through cross-validation affirm the feasibility and efficacy of the proposed methodologies, thus paving the way for enhanced virtual clinical training platforms.
在医学教育中,提高思维能力至关重要。虚拟诊断与治疗平台(VP)通过交互式患者访谈(模拟患者互动)来提升医学生的诊断能力。通过分析这些访谈中提出的问题,VP评估学生在病史询问方面的能力,从而洞察他们的思维能力。本研究旨在从病例摘要和患者访谈中提取见解,以改进医学教育中的评估和反馈。
本研究采用系统方法,利用基于简单长短期记忆(LSTM)的网络和基于暹罗网络的网络进行知识点分类,并结合交叉验证技术。所审查的数据集源自台湾地区第一年至第三年的“临床诊断与治疗技能竞赛”。该方法包括从病例摘要和患者访谈中提出的顺序问题生成知识点。然后使用指定的神经网络架构对这些知识点进行分类。
实验结果显示出有前景的成果,特别是当使用基于暹罗网络的网络进行知识点分类时。通过重复(分层)10折交叉验证,所达到的准确率始终超过93%,标准差小于0.007。这些结果强调了所提出方法在增强虚拟临床诊断系统方面的有效性。
本研究强调了利用先进神经网络架构,特别是基于暹罗网络的网络,在虚拟临床诊断系统中进行知识点分类的可行性。通过有效地辨别和分类从病例摘要和患者访谈中得出的知识点,这些系统为医学教育中了解学生的思维能力提供了宝贵的见解。通过交叉验证获得的稳健准确率证实了所提出方法的可行性和有效性,从而为增强虚拟临床培训平台铺平了道路。