Revel Marion, Groh Ksenia, Bertoli Jessica, Degeratu Mihai-Ovidiu, Fischer Melanie, Fischer Stephan, Hoekman Jarno, Jozef Barbara, Li Roman, Mosimann Sven Lukas, Vom Berg Colette, Županič Anže, Truffer Bernhard, Schirmer Kristin
Department of Environmental Toxicology, Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Dübendorf, Switzerland.
Department of Environmental Systems Science, ETH Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland.
Environ Toxicol Chem. 2025 Sep 1;44(9):2648-2658. doi: 10.1093/etojnl/vgaf028.
Given the need to reduce animal testing for environmental risk assessment, we aim to develop a fish invitrome, an alternative fish modular framework capable of predicting chemical toxicity in fish without the use of animals. The central module of the framework is the validated RTgill-W1 cell line assay that predicts fish acute toxicity of chemicals (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development test guideline 249). Expanding towards prediction of chronic toxicity, the fish invitrome includes two other well-advanced modules for chemical bioaccumulation/biotransformation and inhibition of fish growth. This framework is expected to continuously evolve with the development of modules that predict, for instance, neurotoxicity and reproductive toxicity. We envisage the fish invitrome framework becoming part of the broader academic field of new approach methodologies (NAMs), where it will remain flexible and open to integration of new developments from research groups around the world. To accelerate the development and uptake of this framework, we strive for transdisciplinarity, integrating both natural and social sciences, along with broader stakeholder interactions. A stepwise socio-technical approach was chosen, where mainstreaming the fish invitrome involves progressive adoption across various ecotoxicological contexts. The framework will be codesigned with stakeholders from academia, industry, and regulatory bodies. Rather than aiming for immediate regulatory acceptance, this approach aims to build trust and familiarity with fish cell line-based testing among stakeholders. By doing so, it encourages broader use of the framework in practical applications while gradually overcoming institutional, cultural, and technical barriers. Additionally, establishing a clear roadmap for mainstreaming the fish invitrome will help identify and address challenges to its uptake, ensuring a smoother transition to nonorganismal testing methodologies.
鉴于减少用于环境风险评估的动物试验的必要性,我们旨在开发一种鱼类体外模型,这是一种替代鱼类模块化框架,能够在不使用动物的情况下预测化学物质对鱼类的毒性。该框架的核心模块是经过验证的RTgill-W1细胞系检测方法,可预测化学物质对鱼类的急性毒性(经济合作与发展组织测试指南249)。为了向慢性毒性预测扩展,鱼类体外模型还包括另外两个先进的模块,用于化学物质的生物累积/生物转化以及对鱼类生长的抑制。随着预测例如神经毒性和生殖毒性的模块不断发展,这个框架有望持续演进。我们设想鱼类体外模型框架将成为新方法学(NAMs)这一更广泛学术领域的一部分,在这个领域它将保持灵活性,并对世界各地研究团队的新进展持开放态度,以便进行整合。为了加速这个框架的开发和应用,我们努力实现跨学科,整合自然科学和社会科学,以及更广泛的利益相关者互动。我们选择了一种逐步推进的社会技术方法,将鱼类体外模型纳入主流需要在各种生态毒理学背景下逐步采用。该框架将与学术界、产业界和监管机构的利益相关者共同设计。这种方法并非旨在立即获得监管机构的认可,而是旨在在利益相关者之间建立对基于鱼类细胞系检测的信任和熟悉度。通过这样做,它鼓励在实际应用中更广泛地使用该框架,同时逐步克服制度、文化和技术障碍。此外,为将鱼类体外模型纳入主流制定明确的路线图将有助于识别和解决其应用过程中的挑战,确保向非生物测试方法的平稳过渡。