Turner Philip J, Fanshawe Thomas R, Freeman Jane, Glogowska Margaret, Hay Alastair D, Kenealy Nicola, Llion Owain, Lowe Rebecca, Lown Mark, Moore Michael, Tate Valerie, Wilcox Mark H, Wootton Mandy, Butler Christopher C, Hayward Gail N
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
BMJ Open. 2025 Jan 30;15(1):e090012. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-090012.
Acute uncomplicated urinary tract infection (UTI) is a common condition with potentially serious sequelae that is mostly diagnosed and managed in primary care settings. Around half of all women have a UTI in their lifetime, and a quarter experience an infection caused by organisms resistant to more than one antibiotic. Reducing inappropriate prescribing of antibiotics is a core tenet of antimicrobial stewardship. However, current diagnostics for UTI are unfit for purpose in acute (highest prescribing) settings, being too slow to inform the required immediate decision-making and often confounded by sample contamination.Rapid point-of-care diagnostic tests (POCTs) that facilitate timely decision-making are potential solutions to this problem. Several such tests have reached advanced stages of technology readiness, but their diagnostic performance has not been evaluated in primary care with clinical users. To progress novel tests towards implementation, a diagnostic field study is required, to allow for parallel and sequential evaluation of multiple tests in a primary care population.
We will recruit participants assigned female at birth from primary care clinics in England who contact their clinic with symptoms of acute uncomplicated UTI. Eligible participants will complete a short questionnaire to capture symptoms and symptom severity and will provide a urine sample. Samples will be split and initially tested using novel index tests (POCTs) and conventional urinalysis 'dipstick' at the primary care clinic. The second part of the sample will be processed at a National Health Service-based reference laboratory using a modified reference standard including microscopy, microbiological culture, pathogen speciation and antimicrobial susceptibility testing. The UTI reference standard culture, although based on the national methods, is modified to provide accurate bacterial counts, better to define a microbiological diagnosis of UTI. Susceptibility testing will be performed using 'gold-standard' methods, not usually performed in diagnostic laboratories. The primary outcome will be the diagnostic performance (sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values) of POCTs for detection of UTI and antimicrobial susceptibility for POCTs that include antimicrobial susceptibility testing. Secondary outcomes will include the symptom profile of patients presenting with uncomplicated UTI, a theoretical determination of how use of POCT results might change prescribing, an understanding of POCT failure rate and qualitative capture of the experiences of those using the POCT to deliver the study in primary care clinics.
Ethical approval was received from the London Central Research Ethics Committee (23/LO/0371) and the UK Health Research Authority. We will publish the findings of The plaTform fOr Urinary tract infection diagnostiC evAluatioN evaluations in peer-reviewed medical journals and more broadly following a dissemination plan formulated by a communications specialist in consultation with patients and the public.
ISRCTN80937472.
急性单纯性尿路感染(UTI)是一种常见疾病,可能会引发严重的后遗症,大多在初级医疗环境中进行诊断和治疗。大约一半的女性一生中会患一次UTI,四分之一的女性会感染对一种以上抗生素耐药的病原体。减少抗生素的不适当使用是抗菌药物管理的核心原则。然而,目前用于UTI的诊断方法在急性(处方量最高)环境中并不适用,其速度过慢,无法为所需的即时决策提供信息,而且常常受到样本污染的干扰。能够促进及时决策的快速即时诊断检测(POCT)可能是解决这一问题的办法。有几种这样的检测已达到技术成熟的高级阶段,但它们的诊断性能尚未在有临床用户参与的初级医疗中进行评估。为了推动新型检测方法的实施,需要开展一项诊断性现场研究,以便在初级医疗人群中对多种检测进行平行和序贯评估。
我们将从英国的初级医疗诊所招募出生时被指定为女性且因急性单纯性UTI症状前来就诊的参与者。符合条件的参与者将完成一份简短问卷,以记录症状和症状严重程度,并提供一份尿液样本。样本将被分成两份,首先在初级医疗诊所使用新型指标检测(POCT)和传统尿液分析“试纸”进行检测。样本的第二部分将在基于国民医疗服务体系的参考实验室进行处理,采用一种改良的参考标准,包括显微镜检查、微生物培养、病原体鉴定和抗菌药物敏感性检测。UTI参考标准培养方法虽然基于国家方法,但经过改良以提供准确的细菌计数,更好地界定UTI的微生物学诊断。敏感性检测将使用“金标准”方法进行,而这种方法通常不在诊断实验室进行。主要结果将是POCT检测UTI的诊断性能(敏感性、特异性、阳性和阴性预测值)以及包括抗菌药物敏感性检测的POCT的抗菌药物敏感性。次要结果将包括患单纯性UTI患者的症状特征、对使用POCT结果可能如何改变处方的理论判定、对POCT失败率的了解以及对在初级医疗诊所使用POCT进行研究的人员经验的定性记录。
已获得伦敦中央研究伦理委员会(23/LO/0371)和英国健康研究管理局的伦理批准。我们将在同行评审的医学期刊上发表“用于尿路感染诊断评估的平台(The plaTform fOr Urinary tract infection diagnostiC evAluatioN)”评估的结果,并根据与患者和公众协商后由传播专家制定的传播计划更广泛地进行传播。
ISRCTN80937472。