Harrison Laura, Reynolds Emma, Quitmann Claudia, Till Luisa, Franke Bernd, Zeitz Christin, Danquah Ina, Herrmann Alina
Heidelberg Institute of Global Health (HIGH), Universitätsklinikum Heidelberg, Medizinische Fakultät der Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Deutschland.
Heidelberg Institute of Global Health (HIGH), Universitätsklinikum Heidelberg, Medizinische Fakultät der Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Deutschland.
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2025 Feb;192:77-87. doi: 10.1016/j.zefq.2024.12.003. Epub 2025 Jan 30.
In order to ensure a healthy diet for the world's population within planetary boundaries, the EAT-Lancet Commission has made recommendations for a "Planetary Health Diet" (PHD). Due to the special responsibility of the health sector for healthy living conditions, offering food provision in line with the Planetary Health Diet is a sensible thing to do for health facilities. With this in mind, we evaluated the acceptance, costs and reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions through a correspondingly modified food offer in the cafeteria of a large university hospital.
For three months, a lunch menu adapted to the recommendations of the PHD and information material on sustainable nutrition were offered in the hospital cafeteria. Customers in this cafeteria (intervention group) and in all other hospital cafeterias (control group) completed a questionnaire before (from 12/2022 to 01/2023) and after (from 03/2023 to 04/2023) the intervention period. In this questionnaire, customers were asked how satisfied they were with the sustainable food offer using German school grades (from 1 to 6). We calculated the difference-in-differences (DID), 95% confidence intervals (CIs) and p-values for the school grades. Open-ended questions were used to learn about customers' perception of health and sustainability aspects of the food supply and written feedback analysed qualitatively. We conducted a bottom-up analysis of the greenhouse gas emissions of the different lunch menu lines based on the main ingredients of the dishes and calculated cost differences between the vegan menu line and the conventional menu lines based on food costs.
In the intervention group, the ratings for the sustainability, health, diversity, and flavour of the food on offer improved significantly compared to the control group. The composition of the food (e. g., proportion of meat or vegetables), the product selection (regional, seasonal, organic) and the amount of waste produced were important to the employees when rating the sustainability and healthiness of the food. In the intervention cafeteria, GHG emissions fell by 27 % from 26.2 tonnes to 20.5 tonnes of GHG emissions (saving 5.6 tonnes of GHG emissions) in the second half of the intervention period compared to the previous year, despite a higher number of orders. During the entire intervention period, the intervention group saved about € 4,000 on ingredients.
Due to the robust quasi-experimental study design and in combination with the qualitative results, this study provides initial evidence that a PHD-oriented food offer can increase food-related employee satisfaction.
Switching to sustainable food supply at hospitals is to be recommended due to its cost-effectiveness, positive feedback from employees and the reduction of GHG emissions.
为了在地球边界内确保全球人口的健康饮食,EAT-柳叶刀委员会针对“行星健康饮食”(PHD)提出了建议。鉴于卫生部门对健康生活条件负有特殊责任,为医疗机构提供符合行星健康饮食的食物供应是明智之举。考虑到这一点,我们通过对一家大型大学医院自助餐厅的食物供应进行相应调整,评估了其接受度、成本以及温室气体(GHG)排放量的减少情况。
在三个月的时间里,医院自助餐厅提供了符合行星健康饮食建议的午餐菜单以及关于可持续营养的信息材料。该自助餐厅的顾客(干预组)以及所有其他医院自助餐厅的顾客(对照组)在干预期之前(2022年12月至2023年1月)和之后(2023年3月至2023年4月)完成了一份问卷。在这份问卷中,顾客被要求用德国学校的评分等级(从1到6)来表明他们对可持续食物供应的满意程度。我们计算了评分等级的差异-in-差异(DID)、95%置信区间(CIs)和p值。使用开放式问题来了解顾客对食物供应的健康和可持续性方面的看法,并对书面反馈进行定性分析。我们根据菜肴的主要成分对不同午餐菜单系列的温室气体排放进行了自下而上的分析,并根据食品成本计算了纯素菜单系列与传统菜单系列之间的成本差异。
与对照组相比,干预组对所提供食物的可持续性、健康性、多样性和风味的评分显著提高。在对食物的可持续性和健康性进行评分时,食物的组成(例如,肉类或蔬菜的比例)、产品选择(本地、季节性、有机)以及产生的废物量对员工来说很重要。在干预自助餐厅,与上一年相比,在干预期的下半年,尽管订单数量增加,但温室气体排放量从26.2吨降至20.5吨,减少了27%(节省了5.6吨温室气体排放)。在整个干预期间,干预组在食材方面节省了约4000欧元。
由于稳健的准实验研究设计以及定性结果,本研究提供了初步证据,表明以行星健康饮食为导向的食物供应可以提高员工对食物的满意度。
由于其成本效益、员工的积极反馈以及温室气体排放量的减少,建议医院转向可持续的食物供应。