Conrad Zach, Repoulis Vincent, Zavela Catherine
Department of Kinesiology, William & Mary, Williamsburg, VA, United States.
Global Research Institute, William & Mary, Williamsburg, VA, United States.
Front Nutr. 2025 Jan 17;11:1508601. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2024.1508601. eCollection 2024.
Little is known about the role of pork in sustainable diet patterns, given that it is often aggregated with other animal proteins or not evaluated at all. To address this gap, this study modeled the sustainability impacts of replacing different protein foods with pork in a nationally representative sample of adults in the United States (US).
Data on dietary intake, greenhouse gas emissions (GHGE), cumulative energy demand, water scarcity footprint, land, pesticides, fertilizer nutrients, food prices, and diet quality were obtained from publicly available repositories. A food substitution model was constructed to evaluate the change in each sustainability impact when 1-3 servings of beef, poultry, seafood, eggs, or legumes were replaced by pork.
Modeled substitution of beef with pork was associated with reductions in GHGE, land, pesticides, and fertilizer nutrients by 11-35%, and substitution of seafood with pork was associated with reductions in cumulative energy demand by 6% and diet cost by <1%. All other substitutions led to an increase in sustainability impacts of up to 5%, including all outcomes associated with substituting poultry, eggs, and legumes with pork.
The US federal government can play an important role in improving data collection methods that distinguish between pork and other meats. This can facilitate further research to evaluate sustainability trade-offs, which can inform clinical practice and public policy to support informed food choices for consumers.
鉴于猪肉通常与其他动物蛋白归为一类或根本未被评估,人们对猪肉在可持续饮食模式中的作用知之甚少。为填补这一空白,本研究对美国全国代表性成年样本中用猪肉替代不同蛋白质食物的可持续性影响进行了建模。
从公开数据库获取饮食摄入量、温室气体排放(GHGE)、累积能源需求、水资源稀缺足迹、土地、农药、肥料养分、食品价格和饮食质量等数据。构建了一个食物替代模型,以评估用猪肉替代1 - 3份牛肉、家禽、海鲜、鸡蛋或豆类时,每种可持续性影响的变化。
用猪肉替代牛肉的模型显示,温室气体排放、土地、农药和肥料养分减少了11% - 35%,用猪肉替代海鲜使累积能源需求减少了6%,饮食成本降低了不到1%。所有其他替代导致可持续性影响增加高达5%,包括用猪肉替代家禽、鸡蛋和豆类的所有相关结果。
美国联邦政府可在改进区分猪肉和其他肉类的数据收集方法方面发挥重要作用。这有助于进一步研究评估可持续性权衡,为临床实践和公共政策提供参考,以支持消费者做出明智的食物选择。