López-Del-Hoyo Yolanda, Fernández-Martínez Selene, Perez-Aranda Adrian, Monreal-Bartolomé Alicia, Barceló-Soler Alberto, Camarero-Grados Loreto, Armas-Landaeta Carilene, Guzmán-Parra José, Carbonell Vera, Campos Daniel, Chen Xinyuan, García-Campayo Javier
Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain.
Institute of Health Research of Aragon, Zaragoza, Spain.
J Med Internet Res. 2025 Feb 3;27:e59653. doi: 10.2196/59653.
The high levels of sustained stress that health professionals often experience are a significant risk factor for developing mental health problems, such as anxiety, depression, and somatic symptoms, that not only affect their well-being but also have major social and organizational consequences. Different interventions, including those based on third-wave psychotherapy principles (ie, mindfulness, compassion, and acceptance), have proven to be effective in reducing stress in this population. Among them, those delivered on the web constitute a promising alternative with notable advantages in accessibility and flexibility, but some adherence inconveniences may limit their efficacy.
This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the MINDxYOU program, a web-based self-guided intervention based on third-wave psychotherapy principles, to reduce perceived stress and promote mental health in a sample of health professionals.
In a stepped-wedge cluster randomized design, 357 health professionals from health centers in Aragon and Málaga, Spain, were recruited. They were divided into 6 clusters-3 per region-and randomly assigned to 1 of the 3 sequences, each starting with a control phase and then transitioning to the intervention phase (the MINDxYOU program) after 8, 16, or 24 weeks. This self-guided, web-based program, designed to be completed over 8 weeks, included weekly contact (via WhatsApp, call, or email) from the research team to promote adherence. Participants were assessed on the web every 8 weeks for 5 assessments. Perceived stress was the study's primary outcome, with additional measures of clinical factors (anxiety, depression, and somatization) and process variables (resilience, mindfulness, compassion, and acceptance).
The program was initiated by 229 participants, 112 (48.9%) of whom were completers (ie, completed at least 3 of the 4 modules). Perceived stress demonstrated a significant reduction both when considering the entire sample (β=-1.08, SE 0.51; P=.03) and the sample of completers (β=-1.84, SE 0.62; P=.003). The proportion of participants reflecting "low stress" increased after the treatment (n=90, 46.6% vs n=100, 28.8% at baseline). Intracluster analysis revealed that pre- versus postintervention moderate effects were present in 2 clusters (Cohen d=0.46 and 0.62), and these were maintained in subsequent assessments. The linear mixed-effects models also showed that depression, anxiety, and somatization, as well as resilience, self-compassion, and some mindfulness facets, experienced significant improvements (P<.05) when comparing the intervention and control phases.
The MINDxYOU program was effective in reducing perceived stress and promoting mental health, as well as increasing resilience, mindfulness facets, and self-compassion. These effects suggest that participants experienced a tangible improvement that could potentially enhance their well-being. Adherence to the intervention was moderate, while program use was notable compared to similar interventions. Finding ways to promote adherence to the intervention would contribute to increasing the effectiveness of this program.
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT05436717; https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05436717.
INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): RR2-10.1186/s12912-022-01089-5.
卫生专业人员经常经历的高水平持续压力是导致心理健康问题的重要风险因素,如焦虑、抑郁和躯体症状,这些问题不仅影响他们的幸福感,还会产生重大的社会和组织后果。不同的干预措施,包括基于第三波心理治疗原则(即正念、慈悲和接纳)的措施,已被证明能有效减轻这一人群的压力。其中,基于网络的干预措施是一种有前景的选择,在可及性和灵活性方面具有显著优势,但一些依从性方面的不便可能会限制其效果。
本研究旨在评估MINDxYOU项目的有效性,该项目是一种基于网络的、基于第三波心理治疗原则的自我引导干预措施,旨在减轻卫生专业人员样本中的感知压力并促进其心理健康。
采用阶梯式楔形整群随机设计,招募了来自西班牙阿拉贡和马拉加卫生中心的357名卫生专业人员。他们被分为6个整群,每个地区3个,并随机分配到3个序列中的1个,每个序列均从对照阶段开始,然后在8周、16周或24周后过渡到干预阶段(MINDxYOU项目)。这个基于网络的自我引导项目设计为在8周内完成,包括研究团队每周(通过WhatsApp、电话或电子邮件)进行联系以促进依从性。参与者每8周在网上接受一次评估,共进行5次评估。感知压力是该研究的主要结果,还包括临床因素(焦虑、抑郁和躯体化)和过程变量(心理韧性、正念、慈悲和接纳)的额外测量。
229名参与者启动了该项目,其中112名(48.9%)为完成者(即完成了4个模块中的至少3个)。在考虑整个样本时(β=-1.08,标准误0.51;P=.03)以及完成者样本中(β=-1.84,标准误0.62;P=.003),感知压力均显著降低。治疗后反映“低压力”的参与者比例增加(n=90,46.6% 对比基线时n=100,28.8%)。整群内分析显示,2个整群在干预前后存在中等效应(科恩d=0.46和0.62),且在后续评估中得以维持。线性混合效应模型还显示,在比较干预阶段和对照阶段时,抑郁、焦虑和躯体化,以及心理韧性、自我慈悲和一些正念方面均有显著改善(P<.05)。
MINDxYOU项目在减轻感知压力、促进心理健康以及提高心理韧性、正念方面和自我慈悲方面均有效。这些效果表明参与者经历了切实的改善,这可能会提升他们的幸福感。干预的依从性中等,而与类似干预措施相比,该项目的使用率较高。找到促进干预依从性的方法将有助于提高该项目的有效性。
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT05436717;https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05436717。
国际注册报告标识符(IRRID):RR2-10.1186/s12912-022-01089-5。