Alsharif Walaa, Alrehily Faisal, Alhazmi Fahad H, Greeballah Awadia, Qurashi Abdulaziz A, Aldahery Shrooq, Alahmadi Adnan, Alsaedi Amirah, Alshoabi Sultan, Alshamrani Khalid M, Omer Awatif M, Aljuhani Raghad
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, College of Applied Medical Sciences, Taibah University, Madinah, Saudi Arabia.
Applied Radiologic Technology, College of Applied Medical Science, University of Jeddah, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
PLoS One. 2025 Feb 4;20(2):e0314332. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314332. eCollection 2025.
To examine the current application of Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) among radiology professionals, including radiologists and radiographers, in Saudi Arabia and to identify challenges in order to propose suitable future improvement strategies if it is required.
A mixed-method design was used in this study. A survey consisting of 23 questions addressing research activities and EBP within radiology departments was sent to radiology personnel. The sample size of the quantitative phase of the study was determined using a formula specific for an infinite or unknown population. The formula used was n = P(1-P)Z2/d2, which resulted in a required sample size of 384 participants. A total of 345 participants; however, 45 did not fully complete the questionnaire and were therefore excluded. The data were analyzed using SPSS version 27. Inferential statistics, including non-parametric tests such as the Mann-Whitney U Test and the Kruskal-Wallis Test, were used to assess the influence of demographic factors on perceptions and challenges related to the adoption of evidence-based practice (EBP) in research within Saudi Arabia. Additionally, 20 semi-structured interviews were conducted with radiology personnel across the country. The sampling technique for the qualitative phase of the study was guided by the study's objectives and the unique characteristics of the research group. The participants were purposively sampled in order to include radiologists and radiographers who work in different types of hospitals (public, semi-public, private) in Saudi Arabia. Responses from the interviews were coded, and key themes were identified following Miles and Huberman's framework.
The findings revealed a positive attitude towards research and EBP among Saudi radiology personnel. Over half of the participants (74.3%) strongly agreed that they understood and were familiar with EBP. They also felt confident in their ability to conduct scientific research in radiology (Mean = 4.27) and believed that they should actively initiate projects (Mean = 4.10). Radiologists reported a higher level of agreement compared to radiographers regarding their familiarity with EBP and their ability to critically evaluate the quality of research (P-value = <0.05). However, participants indicated lower level of agreement about their ability to develop their current practice based on EBP and engage in discussions with colleagues about research evidence. Key challenges identified include a lack of training, insufficient support and limited autonomy, which may hinder EBP implementation.
This study underscores the need for comprehensive education, ongoing training and a supportive organisational culture to enhance EBP adaption.
研究循证实践(EBP)在沙特阿拉伯放射科专业人员(包括放射科医生和放射技师)中的当前应用情况,并识别挑战,以便在需要时提出合适的未来改进策略。
本研究采用混合方法设计。向放射科人员发送了一份包含23个问题的调查问卷,内容涉及放射科的研究活动和循证实践。使用针对无限或未知总体的特定公式确定研究定量阶段的样本量。所用公式为n = P(1 - P)Z2/d2,得出所需样本量为384名参与者。共有345名参与者;然而,45名参与者未完全完成问卷,因此被排除。使用SPSS 27版对数据进行分析。推断性统计,包括非参数检验,如曼-惠特尼U检验和克鲁斯卡尔-沃利斯检验,用于评估人口统计学因素对沙特阿拉伯放射学研究中与采用循证实践(EBP)相关的认知和挑战的影响。此外,还对全国各地的放射科人员进行了20次半结构化访谈。研究定性阶段的抽样技术以研究目标和研究群体的独特特征为指导。参与者是有目的地抽样,以纳入在沙特阿拉伯不同类型医院(公立、半公立、私立)工作的放射科医生和放射技师。访谈的回答进行了编码,并按照迈尔斯和休伯曼的框架确定了关键主题。
研究结果显示沙特放射科人员对研究和循证实践持积极态度。超过一半的参与者(74.3%)强烈同意他们理解并熟悉循证实践。他们也对自己在放射学领域进行科学研究的能力充满信心(平均值 = 4.27),并认为他们应该积极发起项目(平均值 = 4.10)。与放射技师相比,放射科医生在对循证实践的熟悉程度以及批判性评估研究质量的能力方面报告的认同度更高(P值 = <0.05)。然而,参与者对基于循证实践改进当前实践以及与同事就研究证据进行讨论的能力表示认同度较低。确定的关键挑战包括缺乏培训、支持不足和自主权有限,这些可能会阻碍循证实践的实施。
本研究强调需要全面教育、持续培训和支持性的组织文化来加强循证实践的应用。