Thienpondt Annelies, Van Cauwenberg Jelle, Van Damme Joris, Nagelhout Gera E, Deforche Benedicte
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Ghent University, Corneel Heymanslaan 10, Ghent, B-9000, Belgium.
Research Foundation Flanders (FWO), Brussels, Belgium.
Arch Public Health. 2025 Feb 5;83(1):29. doi: 10.1186/s13690-024-01491-2.
Temporary abstinence campaigns (TAC) are a promising approach to reduce alcohol consumption. This study examined changes in (at-risk) alcohol consumption and determinants of alcohol consumption among Belgian adults participating in the Tournée Minérale Campaign (TMC, Belgian TAC). In addition, moderating effects of age, sex, education level, successfully refraining from alcohol during TMC, risk drinking, drinking levels and binge drinking were investigated.
TMC is a fully automated mass media prevention campaign challenging Belgian adults to refrain from alcohol during the month February. This study includes a baseline, post- (four weeks after TMC) and follow-up (six months after TMC) test using online recruitment and an online questionnaire. Participants were self-selected by signing up on the TMC website. Repeated measures ANCOVAs were used to examine changes over time in alcohol consumption (log transformed due to skewness) and determinants among TMC participants (n = 8,730, 48.4 ± 12.9 years old, 37.4% males) who filled in all three measurements. Moderation effects were assessed for age, sex, education level, successfully refraining from alcohol during TMC, risk drinking, drinking levels and binge drinking at baseline. McNemar tests were used to examine the change in prevalence of risk drinking and binge drinking.
TMC participants showed a significant decrease in weekly alcohol consumption (mean exp(x)-1) and CI) from baseline (6.2 [6.4,6.7]) to post (4.2 [4.1,4.3], F = 22.0, p < .001 d = -2.4 [-2.4,-2.3]) and from baseline to follow-up (5.1 [4.9,5.2], F = 24.2, p < .001, d = -1.5 [-1.5,-1.4]), and an increase from post to follow-up (F = 21.1, p < .001). In the short term (from baseline to post), the decreases were stronger among older, male and lower educated TMC participants, those successfully refraining during TMC, higher risk drinkers and binge drinkers. In the medium term (from baseline to follow-up), changes in alcohol consumption were moderated by education (stronger among lower educated) and risk drinking (increase in lower risk drinkers and decrease in higher risk drinkers). Participants' baseline drinking level moderated changes in alcohol consumption. Both short and medium term increases in alcohol consumption were observed among those with a low drinking level (those who drank 0 to < 4 glasses at baseline), while short and medium term decreases were observed among those with higher drinking levels, i.e. those with moderate (≥ 4 to ≤ 10 glasses), high (> 10 to ≤ 17 glasses) and highest (> 17 glasses) drinking level at baseline. A reduction in the proportion of risk drinkers and binge drinkers and changes in determinants of alcohol consumption (e.g. attitudes towards drinking less alcohol and habit of drinking alcohol) were observed among TMC participants.
TMC participants reported favourable changes in (the underlying determinants of) alcohol consumption in the short and medium term. Higher level drinkers appear to be especially attracted to participate in TMC and to experience the strongest decreases in alcohol consumption. However, without comparison with a control group of non-participants or comparison points, we cannot simply attribute the changes over time to participation in TMC. Future research with a stronger study design is needed to rule out possible bias (e.g., selection bias, seasonal effects or regression to the mean) and to examine mechanisms and longer term effects of TACs.
短期戒酒运动(TAC)是一种很有前景的减少酒精消费的方法。本研究调查了参与矿物巡回赛运动(TMC,比利时的TAC)的比利时成年人中(高危)酒精消费的变化以及酒精消费的决定因素。此外,还研究了年龄、性别、教育水平、在TMC期间成功戒酒、危险饮酒、饮酒量和暴饮对这些变化的调节作用。
TMC是一项全自动的大众媒体预防运动,挑战比利时成年人在2月份戒酒。本研究包括使用在线招募和在线问卷进行的基线、运动后(TMC后四周)和随访(TMC后六个月)测试。参与者通过在TMC网站上报名自行选择。重复测量协方差分析用于检验TMC参与者(n = 8730,年龄48.4±12.9岁,男性占37.4%)中酒精消费(因数据偏态进行对数转换)和决定因素随时间的变化,这些参与者完成了所有三次测量。在基线时评估年龄、性别、教育水平、在TMC期间成功戒酒、危险饮酒、饮酒量和暴饮的调节作用。McNemar检验用于检验危险饮酒和暴饮患病率的变化。
TMC参与者的每周酒精消费量(平均指数化值-1及置信区间)从基线(6.2[6.4,6.7])到运动后(4.2[4.1,4.3],F = 22.0,p <.001,d = -2.4[-2.4,-2.3])以及从基线到随访(5.1[4.9,5.2],F = 24.2,p <.001,d = -1.5[-1.5,-1.4])均显著下降,从运动后到随访有所增加(F = 21.1,p <.001)。短期内(从基线到运动后),年龄较大、男性、教育程度较低的TMC参与者、在TMC期间成功戒酒者、高危饮酒者和暴饮者的酒精消费量下降幅度更大。从中期来看(从基线到随访),酒精消费的变化受到教育程度(教育程度较低者变化更大)和危险饮酒(低风险饮酒者增加,高风险饮酒者减少)的调节。参与者的基线饮酒量对酒精消费变化有调节作用。饮酒量低的参与者(基线时饮用0至<4杯者)在短期和中期均出现酒精消费增加,而饮酒量较高者,即基线时中度饮酒(≥4至≤10杯)、重度饮酒(>10至≤17杯)和极重度饮酒(>17杯)者在短期和中期出现酒精消费下降。在TMC参与者中,危险饮酒者和暴饮者的比例有所下降,并且酒精消费的决定因素(如对少饮酒的态度和饮酒习惯)也发生了变化。
TMC参与者在短期和中期报告了酒精消费(及其潜在决定因素)的有利变化。饮酒量较高者似乎特别愿意参与TMC并经历酒精消费量的最大降幅。然而,由于没有与未参与者的对照组或比较点进行比较,我们不能简单地将随时间的变化归因于参与TMC。需要采用更强有力的研究设计进行未来研究,以排除可能的偏差(如选择偏差、季节效应或均值回归),并研究TAC的作用机制和长期影响。