Muyskens Kathryn, Ang Chloe, Kerr Eric Thomson
Centre for Biomedical Ethics, National University of Singapore - Kent Ridge Campus, Singapore
National University of Singapore, Singapore.
J Med Ethics. 2025 Feb 17. doi: 10.1136/jme-2024-110241.
Epistemic humility has garnered increased attention in recent years, including within the realm of clinical ethics and is increasingly accepted as an important part of patient-centred practice and clinical care. However, while literature on the topic often states what epistemic humility is , there have been few positive definitions given for the term. Further, these few positive definitions downplay the relational nature of epistemic humility, in other words, the ways in which epistemic humility is developed within the clinical encounter through the relationship between doctor and patient. In this paper, we will present a positive account of epistemic humility, situated in ethical medical education and practice, and show how it can be identified, modelled and cultivated. We provide a character-based account of epistemic humility that emphasises the relational nature of epistemic humility, that is, that views epistemic humility as formed through relationships rather than solely inhering in an individual's internal mental processes or external presentation and which is embedded in a social context such as a clinical encounter.
近年来,认知谦逊受到了越来越多的关注,包括在临床伦理学领域,并且越来越被视为以患者为中心的实践和临床护理的重要组成部分。然而,虽然关于这个主题的文献经常阐述认知谦逊是什么,但对该术语给出的正面定义却很少。此外,这少数几个正面定义淡化了认知谦逊的关系本质,换句话说,淡化了认知谦逊在临床诊疗过程中通过医患关系得以形成的方式。在本文中,我们将给出一个基于伦理医学教育与实践的关于认知谦逊的正面阐述,并展示它是如何被识别、塑造和培养的。我们提供了一个基于品格的认知谦逊阐述,强调认知谦逊的关系本质,也就是说,将认知谦逊视为通过关系形成,而非仅仅存在于个体的内在心理过程或外在表现中,并且它嵌入在诸如临床诊疗这样的社会情境中。